Agnes Arnold Forster, a historian and author of 'Nostalgia: A History of a Dangerous Emotion,' shares her expertise on the intriguing evolution of nostalgia, from a deadly disease to a source of joy. The discussion highlights how nostalgia can enhance relationships, uplift moods, and even motivate political action. Forster, alongside a panel of psychologists, explores the emotional layers of nostalgia, particularly during the holiday season, revealing its bittersweet sensations and profound impact on our lives and connections.
Nostalgia has evolved from being considered a deadly disease in the 17th century to a cherished emotion that fosters connections and emotional well-being.
Recent research indicates that engaging with nostalgic memories can alleviate physical pain and enhance relationship satisfaction by boosting mood and connectedness.
Deep dives
Understanding Nostalgia
Nostalgia is described as a bittersweet longing for the past that can evoke both warm feelings and a hint of sadness. Psychologists view it as a physical sensation, often likening it to a cozy blanket that wraps around individuals, though its fleeting nature can leave a longing once it dissipates. Historically, nostalgia was first recognized in the 17th century as a form of homesickness and was even considered a disease that could lead to death, particularly among soldiers and youths away from home. Over time, nostalgia has shifted from a potentially deadly condition to a more benign, emotionally complex experience that is now cherished for its capacity to create warm memories and connections to the past.
Nostalgia's Impact on Behavior
Nostalgia can significantly affect individual behavior and choices, with evidence suggesting that it plays a role in enhancing social connectedness and emotional well-being. Triggers for nostalgic feelings vary, often linked to music, smells, or significant personal experiences that evoke positive recollections of the past. While nostalgia can lead to a rosy view of remembered times, it might cloud individuals’ perception of historical accuracy, sometimes resulting in an inflated sense of how positive the past truly was. Despite potential pitfalls, engaging with nostalgic memories can encourage individuals to appreciate their present and strengthen relationships, thereby serving as a tool for emotional resilience.
The Health Benefits of Nostalgia
Recent studies reveal that nostalgia not only boosts mood but can also physically alleviate pain, offering a unique intersection between psychology and health. Participants instructed to reflect on nostalgic memories reported decreased perceptions of pain when faced with mild discomfort, suggesting nostalgia can trigger positive emotional responses that allay distress. This emotional uplift might stem from nostalgia enhancing feelings of connectedness and pleasure, ultimately modifying one’s pain threshold. Furthermore, engaging in nostalgic activities, such as listening to specific music that invokes cherished memories, can even contribute to improved relationship satisfaction and emotional stability.
Nostalgia as a Therapeutic Tool
Nostalgia is increasingly recognized as a valuable element in therapeutic settings, particularly for individuals experiencing memory loss or feelings of disconnection. Instead of merely recalling past events, nostalgia therapy emphasizes eliciting emotional responses from meaningful experiences, which can enhance the well-being of those suffering from conditions like dementia. It allows caretakers to tap into pleasant feelings tied to their patient's past, fostering positive interactions that uplift mood and provide comfort. Additionally, engaging with nostalgic memories in various forms, such as music, can serve as an effective intervention in counseling, helping individuals forge deeper connections to their experiences and elevate their emotional state.
In the first of two special holiday episodes, Claudia Hammond and an expert panel of psychologists look back, nostalgically.
At this festive time of year, you might be thinking wistfully about Christmas past – perhaps you’ll be rewatching old films, arguing over a game of Monopoly, or listening to Christmas music that drives you mad. Maybe you are looking back with rose-tinted spectacles on the Christmases gone by that seem somehow more magical than they are now. Or perhaps it’s hard to look back without feeling a tinge of sadness. Whether you fall on the more bitter or more sweet side of bittersweet, this is the bittersweet feeling of nostalgia. And it is particularly rife at this time of year.
But nostalgia wasn't always just a feeling. Historian Agnes Arnold Forster tells Claudia and the panel that once it was viewed as a disease so deadly that it appeared on thousands of death certificates. And now this poignant emotion stirs political action, bonds us to others, and guides our very understanding of ourselves.
Peter Olusoga, Senior Lecturer in Psychology at Sheffield Hallam University, Daryl O’Connor, Professor of Psychology at the University of Leeds, and Catherine Loveday, Professor of Cognitive Neuroscience at the University of Westminster, join Claudia in the studio to discuss how leaning into nostalgia can help us feel better, reduce pain and even inject a bit of romance into life.
Presenter: Claudia Hammond
Producer: Lorna Stewart
Content Editor: Holly Squire
Studio Manager: Emma Harth
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode