Keen On America The 1984 NYC Subway Vigilante: Self Defense or Racial Rage?
Jan 18, 2026
Elliot Williams, a CNN legal analyst and author of *Five Bullets*, dives deep into the controversial 1984 NYC subway shooting by vigilante Bernie Goetz. He discusses the multifaceted narratives surrounding the case, highlighting how perceptions shift based on race. Williams explores the media's role in shaping public fear, the implications of racial politics, and contrasts legal outcomes with moral justice. He also reflects on the enduring impact of this event on contemporary discussions about vigilantism and race in America.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
1984 Case Mirrors Today's Divides
- The Goetz case echoes modern debates about crime, media bias, and vigilantism in America.
- Elliot Williams argues these 1984 issues remain potent and shape current politics and safety fears.
Few Agreed Facts, Many Debates
- Only a few facts are uncontested: Goetz shot four Black teenagers, fled, returned, and was convicted for illegal gun possession.
- Everything else about motives, threats, and intent remains fiercely debated and unresolved.
Rashomon On The Subway
- The story has a Rashomon quality: eyewitness accounts conflict on how the shooting unfolded.
- Even details like the pacing of shots differ, complicating any single authoritative narrative.
