Todd McGowan, an author known for his insights on philosophy and psychoanalysis, discusses his latest work on alienation. He explores the complexities of societal disconnection amidst contemporary crises, emphasizing why embracing alienation can lead to true political emancipation. McGowan examines the intersection of alienation and creativity, sharing how personal writing influences narratives. The conversation also delves into the representation of alienation in cinema, linking it to broader themes of identity and community in modern society.
Embracing alienation can serve as a foundation for personal identity and revolutionary politics in a modern context.
Literature and film act as vital mediums to authentically explore and express the complexities of alienation within human experience.
Deep dives
The Concept of Alienation
Alienation is presented as an essential aspect of modernity and human experience, traditionally viewed as a problem to be solved. The speaker emphasizes that instead of overcoming alienation, individuals should embrace it as a part of their identity. This shift reflects on the historical and theoretical context, particularly within Marxist discourse, where alienation was often seen negatively. A significant insight is drawn from examining the term 'community,' where the author articulates a critical perspective, suggesting a preferred focus on the concept of the public rather than the commonly used notion of community.
Literary and Artistic Representations
The discussion highlights the role of literature and art in depicting alienation, specifically through the lens of modernity. Works such as Shakespeare's plays and modern novels are referenced as effective in communicating the feeling of estrangement inherent in human existence. The speaker critiques the memoir format for its tendency to gloss over alienation, suggesting that more structured artistic forms can more authentically express this theme. By examining the first-person narrative and modernist literature, the speaker suggests that these formats can capture the complexity of alienation more truthfully.
Cinematic Examples of Embracing Alienation
Several films are analyzed to illustrate the theme of embracing alienation, with 'Fight Club' emerging as a quintessential example. The protagonist's self-destructive actions serve as a metaphor for societal disconnection, ultimately striving for a more profound understanding of their alienation. Other films, such as 'Miss Sloan' and 'Michael Clayton,' showcase characters who sacrifice their identities in pursuit of larger truths, highlighting the tension between personal and collective alienation. These examples underline that true understanding of alienation often requires stepping outside conventional societal roles.
Politics and Alienation
The speaker delves into the relationship between alienation and political movements, suggesting that revolutionary moments often arise from deep-seated feelings of alienation. While political uprisings may lack clear alternatives, they serve as expressions of discontent with the existing order. Referencing the Arab Spring, the speaker points out that such movements can become co-opted if they do not maintain a connection with the underlying alienation. Ultimately, the speaker posits that politics should harness the concept of alienation to forge new forms of public spaces and commons, crucial for fostering genuine collective identity.
The subject is divided from itself even in the form in which it is completely at home...so in this first episode we're talking the status of alienation in our current context of serial crisis and what Anna Kornbluh describes as cultural immediacy.
What does a politics of alienation have to say about ‘the day after’ or how would it look in the day after? What is the significance of place and community? Why is the violence of the death drive and its self-sabotage the first emancipation that subsequently establishes the pattern for all later political acts of emancipation?
We also get into Žižek's ontology & fate, determinism, and the forced choice of alienation.
Part two will be out next week...
Enjoy!
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode