The Thinking Muslim Why Shadi Hamid Defends American Power | Hats Off with Imam Tom
10 snips
Dec 12, 2025 
Shadi Hamid, a political analyst and author of The Case for American Power, dives into the complexities of U.S. foreign policy. He discusses why he believes America is still worth defending and the regenerative potential of democracies. The conversation explores how moral objectives require political power, America's appeal to immigrants, and the impact of U.S. hegemony on global democracy. Shadi also tackles criticisms from the Muslim community and highlights the importance of civic engagement for policy change.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
American Power Is Still Dominant
- Shadi Hamid argues America remains the uncontested global power and can be an instrument for good if its citizens act.
- He warns realistic alternatives (China, Russia) lack appeal or are worse, so working within U.S. power matters.
Power Enables Moral Action
- Morality often requires power to be enacted; without power ideals remain aspirational.
- Hamid says democracies allow redress and citizen-driven change, so participation matters.
Parents' Naturalization As Proof
- Hamid describes his immigrant parents' naturalization as evidence of America's openness to newcomers.
- He contrasts U.S. assimilation with European states where newcomers often remain socially excluded.
