Trump 2.0 and the Law (Robert Wright & Jack Goldsmith)
Feb 25, 2025
auto_awesome
Jack Goldsmith, a Harvard Law professor and former member of the George W. Bush Justice Department, discusses the intricate dance of presidential power during Trump's administration. He explores the implications of Trump’s military leadership changes and the challenges of legal accountability. The conversation dives into the controversial ‘unitary executive theory’ and examines whether it poses a constitutional threat. Goldsmith unpacks the chaos in governance and the potential for Trump to navigate legal challenges, highlighting the broader implications for democracy.
The podcast discusses the significant concerns regarding the expansion of presidential power under Trump, emphasizing potential threats to democratic balance and legal norms.
A central theme revolves around the implications of Trump's actions on civil-military relations and the potential risks posed by his personnel decisions.
Deep dives
Concerns About Presidential Power Expansion
The discussion highlights the growing concerns surrounding the expansion of presidential power under Donald Trump's administration. Critics argue that Trump's actions threaten the balance of democracy, especially his attempts to consolidate authority within the executive branch. There is an ongoing debate over whether his actions constitute clear legal violations or simply deviations from established norms. The complexities of legal interpretations and the lack of decisive judicial involvement exacerbate these concerns and challenge the traditional checks and balances.
Military and Legal Appointments as a Point of Concern
Trump's recent firings and replacements of key military and legal officials raise alarm about the potential implications for civil-military relations. Replacing top legal officers in the armed forces posed risks regarding the legal and ethical conduct of military operations, particularly in domestic contexts. Observers are worried about the motivations behind these changes, suggesting that they may reflect an attempt to create a more loyal and compliant legal environment in the military. Such actions can undermine the critical role that military legal advisors play in maintaining ethical standards and lawful military conduct.
Legality of Actions and Judicial Oversight
A significant aspect of the dialogue revolves around the legality of Trump's decisions and whether they defy established laws. One of the key examples provided was Trump's handling of the TikTok ban, where he reportedly instructed the Attorney General to disregard an existing congressional law. The implications of a president choosing to ignore laws could shift the balance of power significantly, presenting challenges to congressional authority. While some actions may be legally questionable, determining standing for lawsuits remains a hurdle to accountability.
The Unitary Executive Theory and Its Implications
The conversation delves into the evolving concept of the unitary executive theory, which argues that the president has extensive control over the executive branch. This theory has its roots in historical debates and has gained traction among conservatives, particularly in the context of Trump's presidency. Critics warn that the practical application of this theory could lead to significant overreach and threaten the institutional balance of power. The ongoing struggle over the interpretation and enforcement of this theory may shape future legal and constitutional frameworks.
Intro ... Jack’s experience with presidential power ... Unpacking Trump’s Pentagon and DOJ purges ... Which legal battles could Trump win? ... The Trump-Musk chaos: bug or feature? ... How Trump is putting “unitary executive theory” into practice ... Is a unitary executive unconstitutional? ... Heading to Overtime ...
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode