Explore the evolving power dynamics between workers and bosses throughout history. Journey back to 1347 Sicily, where the Black Death unexpectedly empowered laborers with better wages and working conditions. Then, shift to the Industrial Revolution, where the Luddites rose against machines threatening their jobs, showcasing the struggle of skilled labor in the face of rapid technological advancement. This discussion highlights the complexities of labor's past and its implications for the present and future.
The economic upheaval from the Black Death in 1347 significantly empowered workers, allowing them to negotiate better wages and conditions.
The Luddite movement illustrates a desperate response to technological disruption in the Industrial Revolution, emphasizing the ongoing struggle between labor and automation.
Deep dives
The Historical Context of Labor Movements
The episode delves into the historical significance of labor movements by examining the crucial balance between workers and employers throughout history. It highlights how economic crises and societal shifts can abruptly alter this balance, empowering workers during periods of labor shortage. Specifically, the discussion emphasizes the uncertainty surrounding job security in the age of AI and automation, as people fear for their roles in a rapidly changing economy. By using labor history as a lens, it encourages listeners to reflect on current labor conditions and the dynamics of worker rights versus employer interests.
The Black Death and Economic Transformation
The Black Death serves as a key case study in the episode, illustrating how a significant reduction in the labor force led to profound economic changes in Europe. The pandemic drastically diminished Europe's population, creating a labor shortage that empowered remaining workers to negotiate higher wages and better working conditions. Historical accounts reveal that wages in Florence doubled during this period, as well as changes in contract stipulations that favored laborers. This shift not only affected individual bargaining power but also contributed to social mobility as people sought new opportunities in the workforce.
The Rise and Fall of the Luddites
The episode explores the Luddite movement, where skilled cloth workers revolted against machines that threatened their livelihoods during the Industrial Revolution. These workers, feeling disenfranchised by the automation of their skilled trades, organized violent protests to destroy machinery they believed would render them obsolete. The narrative illustrates how the Luddites initially gained traction and support but ultimately faced severe repression from the government, leading to harsh punishments for their actions. Despite their failure, the Luddites symbolize the fierce struggle between labor forces and the technological advancements that disrupt traditional work.
Lessons for Today's Workforce
The episode concludes by drawing parallels between historical labor struggles and contemporary challenges faced by workers today. It discusses the cyclical nature of power dynamics between labor and capital, illustrating how periods of worker empowerment often precede significant upheavals. With rising unionization efforts in various industries, from food service to academia, there is a renewed focus on worker rights and negotiating power in today’s economy. These historical insights remind listeners of the importance of recognizing and seizing moments when labor can assert its influence amidst evolving economic landscapes.
Who has the power? Workers or bosses? It changes through the ages, though it's usually the bosses. Today, we look at two key moments when the power of labor shifted, for better and worse, and we ask why then? What does history have to say about labor power right now?
We travel to Sicily, Italy in the year 1347, where the bubonic plague is about to strike. The horror known as the Black Death will remake European society in countless ways, but we'll focus on one silver lining: how economic conditions shifted for workers.
Then we head about 500 years into the future, to an English factory at the dawn of the Industrial Revolution, where textile workers take up arms against the machines taking their jobs and show how rapidly labor supply and demand can change. This is the famed tale of the Luddites, now a byword for knee jerk anti-technology, but the true story has nuance and a desperate but rational violent rebellion.
This series is hosted by Robert Smith and produced by Audrey Dilling. Our project manager is Devin Mellor. This episode was edited by Planet Money Executive Producer Alex Goldmark and fact-checked by Sofia Shchukina.