In this engaging discussion, guests Madeleine Davis, a New Statesman contributor, and Anastasia Berg, co-author of "What Are Children For? On Ambivalence and Choice," explore the global decline in birth rates. They delve into how financial, social, and romantic factors influence the choice to have children. The conversation highlights changing attitudes towards parenthood and the complexities of modern family planning, emphasizing the societal shifts that impact decisions about raising a family.
Economic factors such as high childcare costs contribute significantly to declining birth rates, complicating financial stability for young families.
Cultural attitudes towards parenthood, including a heightened sense of 'readiness' and evolving social norms, influence individuals' decisions about having children.
Deep dives
Fertility Rates and Economic Influences
Fertility rates are declining globally, with many countries reporting figures below the replacement level necessary to maintain population stability. Economic factors are often cited as key contributors to this trend, as high childcare costs and challenging financial situations create obstacles for young families. Despite extensive government incentives aimed at increasing birth rates, such as generous parental leave and subsidized childcare, results can be disappointing. In Norway, for instance, even with significant financial support, the fertility rate has hit record lows, highlighting that economics alone may not be sufficient to spur population growth.
Cultural and Philosophical Factors at Play
The discussion around declining fertility rates extends beyond economic incentives, delving into cultural and philosophical considerations. Many individuals express desires to have children but cite ambivalence and a lack of readiness as significant barriers. Factors such as the quest for a suitable partner and the evolving perception of family life contribute to a complex landscape where societal norms influence personal decisions. Additionally, concerns over climate change and the impact of raising children in an uncertain world shape attitudes toward parenthood, revealing a multifaceted issue that cannot be solved by policy alone.
The Role of Readiness in Family Planning
A noteworthy aspect influencing fertility decisions is the heightened standard of 'readiness' people feel they must meet before starting a family. Individuals today often impose rigorous criteria concerning financial and emotional stability, which can lead to postponing parenthood or deciding against it altogether. This notion of readiness can overshadow the more intrinsic desires for parenthood, complicating the decision-making process. Consequently, societal expectations around achieving a high level of personal and professional success reinforce a cycle of deferral, where individuals delay family planning due to perceived insufficiencies in their lifestyle.
The Involvement of Men in Family Decisions
The conversation about declining fertility rates frequently shifts focus onto women's choices, neglecting the equally important role men play in family planning. A sense of male passivity often permeates discussions about parenthood, with men feeling they should remain neutral on the topic. However, this can lead to women's feelings of isolation when contemplating family decisions. Encouraging men to engage actively in discussions about starting a family, while being sensitive to their partner's autonomy, is crucial for fostering a supportive environment for parenting choices.
Tom Gatti meets authors Madeleine Davis and Anastasia Berg, who have both written on the changing attitudes to child-rearing, to explore the reasons behind these changes.
They discuss why financial, social and romantic circumstances are leading fewer people to have children, and what governments and institutions can or should do to address the issue.
Ask a question for a future episode at www.newstatesman.com/youaskus
Get the New Stateman's political analysis in your inbox every weekday by signing up to our newsletter, Morning Call: morningcall.substack.com
Subscribe to the New Statesman for full access to all our reporting and analysis: www.newstatesman.com/jan24