Carl Zha, host of the Silk and Steel podcast, dives deep into Mao's Cultural Revolution, revealing how his rigid ideology created turmoil for China's Communist Party. Zha shares poignant family anecdotes that highlight the class struggles during this chaotic period. The conversation also addresses Tibet's complex political history and its struggles against feudalism, unveiling the rich yet troubled cultural landscape. Ultimately, Zha presents a nuanced view of Mao's legacy, acknowledging both his transformative achievements and the societal upheavals caused by his leadership.
55:36
forum Ask episode
web_stories AI Snips
view_agenda Chapters
menu_book Books
auto_awesome Transcript
info_circle Episode notes
insights INSIGHT
Mao's Disconnect from Reality
Mao was out of touch with the base and ignored changing material conditions, violating the Marxist scientific method.
His refusal to adjust policies led to major contradictions and failures.
question_answer ANECDOTE
China's Communication Challenges
In 1986 China, making an international phone call meant traveling to a city center post office and waiting hours.
Communication even in big cities was still primitive compared to today, especially in rural 1950s China.
insights INSIGHT
Mao vs Deng Development Approach
Mao used the communist bureaucracy for ideological social engineering, focusing on equality and class struggle.
Deng Xiaoping shifted focus to practical development and improving people's livelihoods, to outcompete capitalism.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
The Little Red Book is a non-conference approved study guide to The Big Book of Alcoholics Anonymous. It distills the essence of the Twelve Steps into actionable insights, providing detailed explanations and actionable advice for those seeking recovery from addiction. The book emphasizes the importance of community support, mutual aid, and personal transformation through the 12-step program. It serves as a lifelong tool for maintaining recovery, promoting personal growth, and encouraging involvement in the supportive community of AA[2][4][5].
Red Star Over China
The Classic Account of the Birth of Chinese Communism
Edgar P. Snow
Red Star Over China is a historical account written by Edgar Snow after he spent four months with the Chinese Communist leaders in 1936. The book provides the first authorized account of Mao Zedong's life, a history of the famous Long March, and insights into the men and women responsible for the Chinese revolution. It includes extensive notes on military and political developments in China, further interviews with Mao, a chronology covering 125 years of Chinese revolution, and detailed biographies of key figures. The book is significant for its unique perspective on the early years of Chinese communism and its prophetic insights into the future of the movement.
Welcome to the third and final chapter in our series with Carl Zha on Mao and the Chinese Revolution. This one covers the sticky wicket of the Cultural Revolution, and the most controversial part of Mao’s legacy. It exposes the danger of a leader being out of touch with the base.
The episode also looks at the complex political history of Tibet, an issue of concern to a few American celebrity Buddhists. (Spoiler alert: the story was rife with class conflict. Isn’t that always the case? What history books and media present as religious persecution turns out to be about money and power.) Tibetan monasteries wanted to maintain their serfs while the communists were into abolishing feudal relations of production. (Second spoiler alert: if you put your money on CIA involvement, you made a wise wager.)
Carl brings the series to life with anecdotes from his own family. This episode is jam-packed with stories of his parents who grew up in the thick of these events. Some of their experiences were specific to their class and status, but they are a colorful illustration of this dramatic and significant period.
Ultimately judgment of Mao’s legacy is mixed. It can be seen as both inspiring and concerning. According to Carl, the official assessment is that “he did 70% good, 30% bad.” He embodies the contradictions of China at the time. Mao should be given credit for massive improvements in the lives of the Chinese people - increasing life expectancy, abolishing illiteracy, raising the status of women, and lifting millions out of poverty.
Carl Zha hosts Silk and Steel, a weekly podcast discussing history, culture, and current events of China and the Silk Road. Support him at patreon.com/silknsteel
Macro N Cheese 
