Episode 5: Baby C ‘The smallest baby I had ever seen’
Nov 7, 2022
auto_awesome
Lucy Letby, accused of injecting a baby with air causing his collapse, is the guest on this week's episode. They discuss the death of baby C, the smallest baby one nurse had ever seen, and the allegations against Letby. The podcast dives into the ongoing trial, expert testimonies, and Letby's defense. It also explores the tragic death of baby C and conflicting arguments regarding the cause. The episode introduces 'The Trial, Ashley Murphy,' a new series covering another murder trial.
The prosecution alleges that Lucy Letby, a neonatal nurse, injected air into baby C's stomach via a feeding tube, causing his collapse and eventual death.
Testimonies suggest that Lucy Letby was present during the collapse and attempted resuscitation of baby C, contradicting her defense's claim that she was not present.
Deep dives
Baby C: The Premature Baby's Tragic Collapse
Baby C, born prematurely at just 30 weeks and weighing less than two pounds, was cared for in the special care baby unit. Despite being small, he was considered stable and improving until the evening of June 13, 2015. Suddenly, baby C collapsed and eventually died. The prosecution alleges that Lucy Letby, a neonatal nurse, injected air into his stomach via a feeding tube, causing him to suffocate. The defense argues that baby C was too ill to be cared for at the hospital and that infection or blockage could have been the cause. Expert witnesses testify that baby C was improving and infection was not the cause of his fatal collapse.
Nurse's Presence and Actions Under Scrutiny
During the critical moments before baby C's collapse, Lucy Letby was being asked to focus on nursery three, where another baby was in distress. However, testimonies suggest that Letby was present in nursery one during the collapse and attempted resuscitation of baby C. Another nurse witnessed Letby standing over the incubator, monitoring the baby's vital signs. The jury heard that Letby appeared calm and made suggestions during the resuscitation efforts. The defense argues that Letby was not present during the collapse and that she was wrongly accused.
Parents' Heartbreaking Goodbye and Controversial Interaction
After baby C's collapse, his parents were given the opportunity to say their goodbyes as he was expected to pass away. However, during this emotional time, Lucy Letby allegedly suggested putting the still-alive baby into a ventilated basket, shocking the parents. The defense argues that Letby was not present during this interaction and that the accusation is unfounded. The baby ultimately survived for several more hours before passing away due to catastrophic brain damage. Expert witnesses find his lack of response during resuscitation attempts to be highly unusual and disputed the defense's claims of infection or blockage as the cause.
This week, Liz and Caroline review what the jury heard about the death of baby C, described by one nurse as the smallest baby she had ever seen. It is alleged that Lucy Letby was close to the infant’s cot and injected him with air causing his collapse, while her defence say she was not responsible and the hospital was not equipped to deal with a baby of his size.
In this episode, we’ll also hear texts Lucy Letby shared with a colleague after this night shift, as well as testimony from the prosecution's expert witnesses who say Baby D did not die of natural causes.