David Goggins vs. Pierre Bourdieu: The Philosophy of STAY HARD!
Jun 24, 2024
auto_awesome
David Goggins, a former Navy SEAL and ultramarathon runner, shares insights on mental toughness and resilience, emphasizing the power of perseverance. He discusses transforming pain into motivation for personal excellence. Pierre Bourdieu's sociological concepts, like social capital, are intertwined, revealing how societal structures impact self-improvement and identity. The conversation explores the duality of Goggins's persona, navigating productivity, and the complexities of ambition in relation to broader societal expectations, encouraging listeners to embrace challenges and push beyond limits.
The podcast debates whether to analyze David Goggins through psychological or sociological lenses, considering both Lacan and Bourdieu's theories.
It introduces Time Energy Theory as a critique of hustle culture, advocating for a sustainable approach to time and productivity.
Goggins' narrative serves as a case study, illustrating the dangers of glorifying extreme discipline within self-help ideologies that overlook systemic barriers.
Bourdieu's concept of habitus is emphasized to understand how individual dispositions are shaped by cultural and social contexts.
Listeners are encouraged to recognize the interplay between consciousness and social structures, examining how external norms affect individual realities.
The speakers address the role of social class in knowledge production, stressing the need for inclusivity in intellectual discourse.
Deep dives
Introduction of CDT and CMT Lectures
The episode discusses the ongoing Critical Doxology Theory (CDT) and Critical Media Theory (CMT) lecture series at Theory Underground, emphasizing their importance as foundational research projects. The speaker highlights that these lectures can be viewed independently without requiring previous attendance, encouraging casual engagement. They outline the launch of seasonal formats for CMT and CDT to broaden accessibility for audiences, while stressing the significance of financial support in allowing the speaker to focus solely on this scholarly work. A small membership group has facilitated this endeavor, indicating a community-driven approach to fostering intellectual exploration.
The Role of David Goggins
David Goggins is introduced as a focal point for discussing hard work ethics and hustle culture within the context of the lecture series. Goggins, known for his extreme physical challenges and motivational tactics, embodies the tension between traditional self-help narratives and the critiques emerging from CDT. His story serves as an illustrative case for how motivational rhetoric can inspire while simultaneously perpetuating unrealistic standards for personal success. Additionally, his relationship with concepts like drive, discipline, and resilience is positioned as a critical examination of self-help ideologies.
Time Energy Theory
The podcast emphasizes the emerging Time Energy Theory, which critiques the hustle culture and self-help paradigms that permeate contemporary discourse. This theory proposes a reevaluation of how individuals allocate their time and energy, advocating for a more sustainable and reflective approach rather than blindly adhering to productivity standards. A historic contrast is drawn between existential time and capitalist time, highlighting the philosophical implications of how society values human experience and productivity. The importance of recognizing these distinctions is placed front and center as a means to resist the pressures of hyper-competitive environments.
The Nature of Understanding
Understanding is discussed as a layered experience shaped by prior knowledge and societal frameworks, urging listeners to reflect on their cognitive processes. The speaker contends that learning from previous projects or understandings should involve an acknowledgment of one’s limitations and the social structures that influence cognition. They point to the necessity of maintaining curiosity and openness in knowledge acquisition rather than seeking immediate closure on concepts. This iterative process of acknowledging and revising one’s understanding is highlighted as a pathway toward deeper intellectual engagement.
Critique of Self-Help Culture
The episode critiques self-help culture, emphasizing the inherent dangers of promoting grind and hustle mentality without acknowledging individual circumstances. Goggins is highlighted as a case study in which the glorification of extreme discipline is examined for its oppressive undercurrents, particularly for those unable to meet such standards. The discussion implicitly challenges listeners to consider the ethics of self-help ideologies that often ignore systemic barriers individuals face. It invites a more nuanced understanding of success, one that is inclusive and considers various forms of struggle and resilience.
Bourdieu's Habitus Concept
Bourdieu's concept of habitus is presented as fundamental to understanding how individual experiences are shaped by cultural and social contexts. Habitus serves as a framework for recognizing how dispositions and practices are often unconsciously formed through societal interactions. The podcast illustrates how habitus dictates the significance of cultural practices, influencing how individuals navigate various social fields. By tracing the developmental roots of habitus, listeners can better comprehend their own trajectory in relation to broader social structures.
Consciousness and Social Structures
The episode explores the interplay between consciousness and social structures, emphasizing how external frameworks often dictate internal thought processes and decisions. It argues that understanding oneself requires an awareness of the social constraints and opportunities within which individuals operate. The podcast ties this understanding to the concept of the 'doxology,' linking it to how societal norms shape perceptions and behaviors. It prompts listeners to examine the extent to which their realities are shaped by external judgments versus internalized beliefs.
The Trap of Curiosity
Curiosity is discussed as a double-edged sword in the pursuit of knowledge, where it can lead to either superficial engagement or profound insights. The speaker emphasizes that the modern landscape often fosters distractions that undermine genuine learning, floating between platforms and stimuli without real engagement. They caution against a form of curiosity that thrives on novelty while sacrificing depth, suggesting an intrinsic link between curiosity and sustained intellectual development. This relates closely to the critiques of contemporary media consumption and its impact on meaningful knowledge acquisition.
Radical Responsibility in Academia
The notion of radical responsibility is highlighted as a critical theme in the discourse surrounding social theory and activism. The speaker argues that scholars and activists must grapple with their positionality and the societal implications of their work. Ignorance of this responsibility can perpetuate existing biases and inequalities within academic and social contexts. The episode calls for scholars to transcend their privilege by actively engaging with marginalized perspectives and histories.
The Impact of Social Class on Identity
The podcast reflects on how social class shapes individual identities and perceptions, particularly in intellectual discourse. It examines the phenomenon of capital accumulation through cultural and social knowledge, where certain groups are disqualified from participation based on socio-economic backgrounds. The speakers discuss the inherent biases and assumptions within academic and professional settings that favor those entrenched in privilege. Understanding this dynamic is positioned as essential for fostering inclusivity and challenging class-based limitations on knowledge production.
Intersections of Theory and Practice
Finally, the discussion turns to the intersections of theory and practice, reflecting on the need to bridge theoretical frameworks with real-world implications. The speakers advocate for a critical approach that does not shy away from the complexities of societal challenges but instead embraces them. They highlight the importance of scalability in understanding theories across diverse contexts, acknowledging the potential for theory to inform activism and vice versa. This holistic perspective invites the audience to engage with complexities while navigating their own intellectual paths.
To try to understand David Goggins, should we turn to psychology or sociology? What about psychoanalysis or critical social theory, e.g. Jacques Lacan vs. Pierre Bourdieu?
Before we can even get there, we first have to situate critical social theory as between or beyond Marxism and phenomenology. That means some recap of Edmund Husserl and Martin Heidegger will be necessary. All of the above thinkers are some of the most complex, difficult, and profound of all time. They all have something utterly essential to gift the field of underground theory. If you feel overwhelmed at any point, just remember, STAY HARD!
ABOUT:
Theory Underground is a research, publishing, and lecture institute. TU exists to develop the concept of timenergy in the context of critical social theory (CST). CST is the umbrella over critical media theory (CMT), critical doxology and timenergy (CDT), critique of libidinal economy (CLE), critique of political economy (CPE), critique of gender and sex (CGS), and critique of psychiatry and therapism (CPT), critique of science and religion (CSR), and many more. To get basically situated in this field you will have to know a handful of important figures from a bunch of areas of the humanities and social sciences. That would be a lot of work for you if not for the fact that Dave, Ann, and Mikey are consolidating hundreds of thousands of hours of effort into a pirate TV-radio-press that goes on tours and throws conferences and shit like that… It’s a crazyfun experiment, and you can enjoy a ton of the content here for free.
GET INVOLVED or SUPPORT
Join live sessions and unlock past courses and forums on the TU Discord by becoming a member via the monthly subscription! It’s the hands-down best way to get the most out of the content if you are excited to learn the field and become a thinker in the milieu: https://theoryunderground.com/products/tu-subscription-tiers
Pledge support to the production of the free content on YouTube and Podcast https://www.patreon.com/TheoryUnderground
Fund the publishing work via the TU Substack, where original works by the TU writers is featured alongside original works by Slavoj Zizek, Todd McGowan, Chris Cutrone, Nina Power, Alenka Zupancic, et al. https://theoryunderground.substack.com/
Missed a course at Theory Underground? Wrong! Courses at Theory Underground are available after the fact on demand via the membership. https://theoryunderground.com/courses
If Theory Underground has helped you see that text-to-speech technologies are a useful way of supplementing one’s reading while living a busy life, if you want to be able to listen to PDFs for yourself, then Speechify is recommended. Use the link below and Theory Underground gets credit! https://share.speechify.com/mzwBHEB
Follow Theory Underground on Duolingo: https://invite.duolingo.com/BDHTZTB5CWWKTP747NSNMAOYEI
See Theory Underground memes and get occasional updates or thoughts via the Instagram :
MUSIC CREDITS Logo sequence music by https://olliebeanz.com/music https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/legalcode Mike Chino, Demigods https://youtu.be/M6wruxDngOk
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
