Stephen Fleming, Professor of cognitive neuroscience, discusses self-deception, cognitive biases, and the limits of self-knowledge. They explore split brain experiments, the challenges of metacognition, and the relationship between metacognition and performance. The podcast also delves into the distinction between reality and imagination, influential books, and representing humanity to future AI.
Metacognition is crucial for self-awareness, allowing us to recognize biases, monitor performance, and make informed decisions.
Self-deception can influence metacognition and decision-making, as the brain constructs models of the self based on limited information.
Developing metacognitive skills helps guard against cognitive biases, enabling accurate self-assessment, information evaluation, and effective interactions.
Deep dives
The Importance of Metacognition
Metacognition, or the ability to think about and understand our own thinking, is a crucial aspect of self-awareness. It allows us to recognize our biases, monitor our own performance, and make more informed decisions. Research suggests that cultivating better metacognition can lead to benefits in various areas, such as education, decision-making, and social interactions. Understanding the factors that influence metacognition, such as cognitive biases and the balance between confidence and self-awareness, can help individuals navigate complex issues and contribute effectively in social settings.
The Role of Metacognition in Self-Deception
Metacognition plays a role in self-deception, as individuals can sometimes hold distorted or biased beliefs about themselves and their abilities. This capacity to deceive oneself stems from the brain's tendency to build models of the self based on limited information. These models are not always accurate but can be functional for certain purposes. For example, overconfidence might be advantageous in motivating individuals to engage in uncertain situations. Understanding how self-deception influences metacognition and how the brain constructs models of the self can provide insights into human behavior and decision-making.
Metacognition and Cognitive Biases
Metacognition can help individuals guard against cognitive biases, which are systematic errors in thinking that can affect decisions and judgments. Examples of cognitive biases include the Dunning-Kruger effect, where individuals with less expertise overestimate their abilities, and the influence of overconfidence on social media. Developing metacognitive skills can lead to a better understanding of one's own biases and limitations, allowing for more accurate self-assessment and decision-making. Improving metacognition can help individuals critically evaluate information and consider alternative perspectives, facilitating more effective interactions in an increasingly complex world.
Training and Improving Metacognition
Metacognition is not a fixed trait and can be developed and improved through training. Various studies suggest that targeted interventions, such as metacognitive training exercises and meditation practices, can enhance metacognitive skills. Developing metacognition can lead to benefits in areas like education, decision-making, and social interactions. However, finding the right balance between confidence and self-awareness is crucial, as excessively high or low metacognition may have unintended consequences. Improving metacognition can empower individuals to navigate complex situations, challenge their own biases, and make more accurate judgments.
Perceptual generative models and imagination
Perception is a constructive process, with top-down projections from the brain playing a crucial role. Imagination involves running this machinery backwards, generating internal representations based on generative models of the external world. Brain imaging studies have shown that imagining objects activates the same neural resources as perceiving them. The overlap between imagination and perception raises the question of how the brain differentiates between the two.
The nature of consciousness and reality monitoring
Conscious experience is grounded in the brain's process of distinguishing perceptual models as reliable reflections of external reality. This is achieved through a process of reality monitoring, where perceptual representations become conscious when identified as reflecting the external world. The feeling of reality in conscious experience is essential for using perceptual models as a basis for rational action. Understanding consciousness as a functional process helps address the challenge of explaining its subjective nature.
Stephen Fleming is a professor of cognitive neuroscience whose work focuses on metacognition - what people think or know about their own minds - and the computational and neural basis of subjective experience. He’s the author of the book Know Thyself: The Science of Self-Awareness.
Today’s topics include the possibility of self deception; cognitive biases and what we can do to guard against them; the benefits and drawbacks of improved metacognition; the relationship between metacognition of conscious experience; the theoretical limits of self knowledge; and other topics.
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers and get access to bonus content, episode notes, and subscriber perks, visit: https://www.matthewgeleta.com/
Chapters:
0:00:00 Intro
0:01:20 Self deception
0:08:08 Cognitive biases and over confidence
0:14:40 Evolution of metacognitive biases
0:18:18 Dunning Kruger effect
0:20:52 Split brain experiments and self narratives
0:25:32 Delusion of self understanding
0:29:54 Isolation of losing touch with reality
0:34:38 How good is our metacognition?
0:38:53 Metacognition vs performance
0:42:46 How trainable is metacognition?
0:46:51 Limits of self knowledge
0:50:52 Theory of self vs others
0:54:16 Benefits from improving metacognition
1:01:40 Psychosis and reality vs imagination
1:14:15 The hard problem of consciousness
1:27:05 Book recommendations
1:33:35 Who should represent humanity to an AI superintelligence?
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
