Heed the Call NFL Podcast with Dan Hanzus & Marc Sessler Dalton Scale 2025: Searching for the NFL’s QB Prime Meridian
Jun 23, 2025
Bill Barnwell, an ESPN analyst and host known for his expertise on quarterback play, joins the conversation to dissect the Dalton Scale for the NFL. They evaluate current QBs like Aaron Rodgers and Tua Tagovailoa to find the new Prime Meridian of quarterback performance. The discussion dives into the complexities of evaluating players beyond their stats, examining the influence of coaching and team dynamics. With insights on evolving QB styles, they explore how durability and context can shape a player's legacy in the league.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Andy Dalton Defines QB Middle Ground
- Andy Dalton represents the middle ground for NFL quarterbacks, marking a clear line between franchise-worthy starters and those needing upgrades.
- His peak year was an MVP-caliber season, but playoff injury and inconsistency kept him from transcending the purgatory status.
Run-Focused NFL Expands QB Threshold
- The Dalton scale today should consider the NFL's shift to a more run-focused, defensive era, affecting quarterback evaluation.
- This shift widens the pool of QBs who could be franchise players, as less emphasis is on high-volume passing.
Baker Mayfield Near Dalton Threshold
- Baker Mayfield exemplifies a quarterback on the cusp of the Dalton line, showing flashes of high production and playoff performance.
- His variability and personality differentiate him from Dalton's bland steadiness; Baker represents a dynamic yet inconsistent talent.