6 Months On: Norman Finkelstein vs Alan Dershowitz
Apr 8, 2024
auto_awesome
Norman Finkelstein and Alan Dershowitz debate the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, focusing on the historical context since 1947, UN resolution 242, Israeli policies in Gaza, and morality within the conflict. Emotions run high as they discuss the complexities of the ongoing tensions in the region.
The conflict between Israel and Palestinians stems from historical tensions dating back to 1947, rooted in fear of displacement and population expulsions.
International organizations have deemed settlements in occupied territories illegal, raising legal concerns and exacerbating the Israeli-Palestinian divide.
Deep dives
Historical Context and Conflict Genesis
The conflict between Israel and the Palestinians dates back to 1947, with the UN division of Palestine into two countries. The fear of Arab displacement and the expulsion of Jewish populations contributed to the tensions. The rejection of proposals and attacks led to significant displacements and a protracted conflict that frames present-day struggles.
Legal Disputes and Settlements
Under international law, settlements in occupied territories are deemed illegal. The International Court of Justice and multiple organizations have condemned the settlements on West Bank as violations of the Fourth Geneva Convention. The issues surrounding settlements have deepened the divide and raise legal concerns regarding occupation practices.
Gaza Blockade and Humanitarian Crisis
Gaza has been subjected to a blockade, described by critics as resembling a concentration camp. International bodies, including the UN, deem the blockade as collective punishment. The restrictions on imports and extreme living conditions have led to a severe humanitarian crisis in Gaza.
Atrocities and Accountability
The discussion delved into the atrocities and terror attacks, notably citing incidents like the martyrdom on October 7th. Differences emerged in justifying acts of violence, with contrasting views on accountability and condemnation of violent acts. The emotional debate highlighted deep-seated divisions on historical perspectives and ethical responsibilities.
Six months on from the Hamas attacks on Israel - we’re debating that context in more detail.
This isn’t an argument about 3,000 years of ancestry and who got there first.
But it is about the conflict and conditions over the last century that frame almost everything about the war still raging today.
Piers' two guests are scholars with deeply opposing views and a feud so well-documented that it has its own Wikipedia page.
But they've both agreed to debate the ideas, not the individuals.
Author and political scientist , Professor Norman Finkelstein & Lawyer and author of 'War against The Jews' and former Harvard Law Professor Alan Dershowitz.