Mises, Hayek, Rand, Friedman: Prophets of Another Faith (McCarraher 9-Audio)
Nov 15, 2020
auto_awesome
Diving into the concept of faith in the 'free market' and how it contrasts with traditional religions. Highlighting the enchanting allure and limitations of neoliberal capitalism. Exploring the shift towards treating economic forces as divine and the implications of blind faith in the market. Reflecting on the origins and consequences of neoliberal ideology.
Neoliberal capitalism enchants the market with godlike laws, promising grand benefits it cannot deliver.
Criticism extends to thinkers like Hayek and Friedman, advocating faith in the market as a panacea for societal challenges.
Deep dives
Understanding Ideological Possession
Ideological possession is described as being hijacked by a personality, idea, or system that appears greater than oneself, projected shadow capable of creating a self-fulfilling prophecy. In this state, individuals surrender their freedom to an absolute, unlike faith in Christianity or other religions that preserve moral freedom. The concept emphasizes the danger of accepting enslavement to earthly powers, urging skepticism and not blind faith towards human ideas.
Neoliberalism and Ideologies as Deities
McCarraher delves into neoliberal utopianism, where figures like Reagan, Thatcher, and Friedman promoted a market-centric belief system as a moral code and a way of life, akin to a religion. Traditionalist conservatism was critiqued as weak and undemocratic, unable to resist the strong influence of neoliberalism. The prophets of neoliberal capitalism, such as von Mises, Hayek, and Friedman, elevated the market to a natural force demanding submission.
Critique of Neoliberal Ideologies
Criticism extends to thinkers like Hayek and Friedman, who viewed religion as constraining freedom and advocated faith in the market's ultimate solution to societal challenges. The faith in the market as a panacea is scrutinized, highlighting the human invention of markets susceptible to errors and control. The radical nature of neoliberal ideology is acknowledged, but its implications raise concerns about its effects on individuals and society.
Inspired by Chapter 26 of Eugene McCarraher’s The Enchantments of Mammon entitled “The New Testament of Capitalism,” I focus on the intellectuals whose ideas undergird the faith in the “free market.” Taking both the concept of faith and what these thinkers said seriously, it’s hard to miss that their perspective runs counter to the faith of people of the book (Judaism, Christianity, Islam) because it enchants the market with godlike and irresistible “laws of nature” and promises to solve all the world’s problems. Neoliberal capitalism is another ideology that, because it is ultimately a human invention, cannot deliver the grandiose benefits it promises, and yet requires of its believers more unquestioning reverence than any truly transcendent power asks of them.
Interested in possible Summer 2021 seminars, one-time sessions, or reading groups? Please fill out this form to be put on the email list: https://forms.gle/WxikMpNx1M64GeTEA