In this captivating discussion, BJ Gooch, a retired librarian with a passion for rare books, and Eric Borsuk, one of the young masterminds behind a notorious book heist, share their unique perspectives. They delve into the audacious planning that led to the theft of $750,000 worth of rare manuscripts and the moral dilemmas they faced. Eric recaps the chaos of the FBI raid, while BJ reflects on the emotional impact of the crime on the preservation of cultural artifacts. Their stories intertwine, revealing the complexities of passion, crime, and consequence.
The heist was driven by a romanticized notion of adventure and the influence of heist films, illustrating the allure of living boldly.
Despite their initial thrill, the students' plan unraveled due to mistakes and the eventual confrontation with law enforcement led to life-altering consequences.
Deep dives
The Bizarre Theft Motivation
A group of disillusioned college students, seeking excitement and a sense of escape, plotted a daring heist to steal rare books from Transylvania University. Spurred by the allure of adventure and inspired by heist films like Ocean's Eleven, the group developed a plan over the course of a year, blending fantasy with reality. Their motivation wasn't purely monetary; they romanticized the idea of living a bold life and saw the heist as a shortcut to achieving that goal. As they delved deeper into planning, their initial excitement morphed into a more serious resolve, igniting a commitment to the audacious scheme.
The Execution of the Heist
The students executed their well-laid plan on December 16, 2004, but a series of missteps and unforeseen complications pushed them to abort their initial attempt. Despite feeling relieved, the group's adrenaline-fueled obsession quickly re-ignited, leading them to reschedule their appointment with librarian B.J. Gooch. On the second attempt, two of the students posed as scholars and subdued Gooch with a stun pen, initiating a chaotic robbery of priceless rare books. Despite their elaborate preparations, the heist quickly spiraled into panic when one of the librarians recognized them, forcing the thieves to flee empty-handed after precariously dropping the stolen items.
The Aftermath and Capture
In the wake of the heist attempt, the authorities scrambled to identify the culprits, using crucial evidence from obtained emails to track the students down. As paranoia set in, the crew continued their ordinary lives while waiting for the inevitable confrontation with law enforcement. On February 11, 2005, a SWAT team raided their residence, and Eric decided to face the consequences rather than escape, ultimately leading to his arrest. This unexpected turn of events dramatically shifted the trajectory of their lives, culminating in their eventual sentencing for multiple federal charges.
Reflections on Regret and Transformation
After serving their sentences, the individuals involved reflected on their actions and the profound impact on both their lives and B.J. Gooch's. Eric expressed deep remorse for the trauma caused, realizing that despite their motivations, they failed to appreciate the value of both the art they sought and the life of the librarian they hurt. Gooch described the psychological scars left by the robbery, feeling violated in a space she cherished. Now transformed by their experiences, the former thieves acknowledge the irony that they could have accessed the rare books legally all along, inviting a sense of tragedy regarding their lost opportunities.
February 11, 2005. FBI agents bust down the door of a cinder block house near the University of Kentucky campus. Amid flash grenades and screaming teens, they arrest three students – plus a fourth student in a nearby dorm. The crime? Stealing almost $750,000 of rare books and manuscripts from the library at Transylvania University. Why did four freshmen decide to actually go through with their real life version of Ocean’s Eleven? And how did they plan to get away with it?
Special thanks to our guests, BJ Gooch, retired special collections librarian; Eric Borsuk, whose memoir is called American Animals: A True Crime Memoir; and Tom Lecky, rare book and manuscript specialist.