Amarica's Constitution The Merits of The Merits
4 snips
May 21, 2025 Dive into the heated legal debate surrounding an executive order on birthright citizenship. Discover the complexities of nationwide injunctions and their constitutional implications, particularly in light of the 14th Amendment. Hear insights from Justices and attorneys as they dissect courtroom arguments and historical precedents. The discussion explores the judiciary's balance with executive authority and the urgent need for clarity from the Supreme Court. Join the conversation on the future of citizenship rights in America!
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Nationwide Injunctions Questioned
- Nationwide injunctions are controversial because they allow a single district judge to issue orders affecting the entire country.
- The question is whether such relief is proper without certified class actions, especially against the federal government.
Merits Are Linked to Procedure
- The merits of the birthright citizenship executive order are clearly against the government according to multiple Supreme Court precedents.
- Justice Sotomayor insists the merits should not be ignored even in the procedural dispute about injunctions.
Catch-Me-If-You-Can Problem
- Justice Kagan highlights the 'catch-me if you can' problem where unconstitutional conduct continues until every harmed individual sues.
- Nationwide injunctions create incentives to expedite Supreme Court resolution, which is crucial for uniformity.
