The Free Press Investigates Spiral | 3. Motive and Opportunity
Oct 28, 2025
Jeffrey Herbstman, a data scientist and former partner of the victim, reveals his emotional turmoil in a gripping 911 call, expressing fear that he might have killed Samantha Woll during a drug-induced break. Listeners get insights into his chaotic night, his fragmented memories, and the community's reaction to his words, which drastically changed public perception. As he navigates police interviews and family concerns, questions arise about the nature of confessions, cannabis-induced paranoia, and the shadow of suspicion looming over his relationship with Samantha.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Panic Call From Out Of Town
- Jeffrey Herbstman called 911 in Kalamazoo saying he thought he might have killed his ex, Samantha Wall.
- He was distressed, taken to police, asked for his lawyer, and later doubted his own memory of events.
Medication And Marijuana Trigger Panic
- Jeff mixed prescribed antidepressants with marijuana and experienced a terrifying, possibly delusional episode.
- He felt panic and belief he might have done something contrary to his values while unable to remember clearly.
Alibi Gaps Fuel Suspicion
- Jeff lacked a solid alibi for part of the night, which intensified his anxiety and suspicion he could be a suspect.
- That absence of alibi became a focal point in how others interpreted his 911 statements.