Prof. Glenn Diesen: Why the US Misunderstands Russia.
Jan 13, 2025
auto_awesome
Prof. Glenn Diesen, a Professor at the University of Southeastern Norway and expert on US-Russia relations, unpacks the layers of American misconceptions about Russia. He critiques neoconservative policies and the tensions that have surfaced post-Cold War, particularly under the current U.S. administration. The discussion shifts to NATO's influence and its risks to European security while highlighting the rising significance of BRICS nations. Diesen emphasizes the need for a new approach to US-Russia relations, advocating for cooperation and a deeper historical understanding.
Russia perceives betrayal from the U.S. due to unaddressed post-Cold War grievances, fueling ongoing geopolitical tensions.
The rise of BRICS nations signifies a shift towards a multipolar world as countries seek alternatives to Western economic dominance.
Deep dives
Understanding Russia's Perception of U.S. Foreign Policy
Russia feels betrayed by the United States due to the lack of a mutually acceptable post-Cold War settlement. Prominent American leaders from the 1990s recognized this failure, leading to ongoing conflicts stemming from these unresolved issues. The Kremlin interprets many symptoms of this discontent, such as territorial disputes and tensions in neighboring regions, as direct consequences of U.S. actions, particularly the expansion of NATO. This misinterpretation often exacerbates conflicts, especially as high-level communication between U.S. and Russian leaders has notably declined in recent administrations.
The Risks of a Weak Russia in U.S. Strategy
The assumption that weakening Russia would enhance U.S. security represents a flawed strategic approach. Leaders like Jake Sullivan argue that sanctions and economic pressure will bolster American safety, yet this overlooks the existential nature of Russian interests in regional security. The belief that economic hardships would compel Russia to retreat is misguided, given their commitment to national survival. This zero-sum mentality, focusing solely on diminishing adversaries, fails to recognize that collaboration and mutual security might lead to more stable international relations.
The BRICS Challenge to Western Dominance
The BRICS nations are gaining significance as countries seek alternatives to the Western-dominated economic structure. The group's growth reflects a broader desire among various nations, including those traditionally allied with the U.S., to avoid dependency and establish independent relationships, particularly with China and Russia. As trust in Western financial systems falters, the impetus for these nations to cooperate grows, highlighting the potential shift in global economic power. This transition threatens the existing dynamics and could lead to an increasingly multipolar world.