Dr. Tripp Fuller, a friendly local internet theologian, dives into the intricate relationship between evil, suffering, and divine power. He navigates the philosophical and theological questions surrounding the existence of evil and whether it challenges the goodness of God. Tripp also highlights the importance of lived experiences, particularly in light of historical injustices like slavery and racism. This engaging discussion encourages reflection on how scripture addresses these profound matters, making theology accessible and relevant to everyday life.
The podcast emphasizes the philosophical dilemma of reconciling God's goodness and omnipotence with the existence of evil and suffering.
Personal narratives and lived experiences are highlighted as vital for understanding the theological discourse on suffering, advocating for compassion over detached reasoning.
Deep dives
The Problem of Evil and Suffering
The episode addresses the philosophical problem of evil, highlighting the dilemma that arises from the coexistence of a perfectly good and all-powerful God with the existence of evil. Classical arguments suggest that if God is good and omnipotent, evil should not exist, leading to the conclusion that either God's goodness, power, or the reality of evil must be questioned. Historical theological perspectives have offered various responses, such as Augustine's view that denies the reality of evil as an absolute entity, asserting instead that evil is a distortion of good, while others, like process theology, reject God's omnipotence as traditionally conceived. This exploration provides a foundation for discussing personal and systemic instances of suffering, emphasizing the need for a nuanced understanding of God in relation to human pain and injustice.
Interpersonal Experiences of Suffering
Personal narratives shared by listeners play a crucial role in understanding the theological discourse on suffering and evil. The host reflects on significant episodes from his life, including the painful death of a family member and his experiences of trauma and injustice, illustrating how individual suffering often requires a response that goes beyond abstract theological debates. The episode emphasizes that these lived experiences call for compassion and solidarity rather than detached theological reasoning, recognizing that the question of God’s goodness and power often arises from one’s personal pain. By elevating individual stories in the conversation about suffering, the podcast seeks to validate the feelings of those grappling with these profound questions.
Solidarity and the Nature of God
The concept of divine solidarity is central to the discussion, particularly in the context of Jesus' crucifixion, where God is portrayed as deeply intertwined with human suffering. The host argues that instead of providing simplistic answers to the problem of evil, the appropriate theological response often involves sharing in the suffering of others, much like Jesus did on the cross. This perspective suggests that God's nature is defined by a commitment to engage in, rather than distance from, human pain and injustice. Such a portrayal of God offers hope and companionship to those in distress, presenting a picture of divine love that fully embraces the complexities of human experience.
1.
Exploring the Nature of Evil and Suffering in Theological Context
Welcome to a special bonus episode of the Theology Nerd Podcast with the Dr. Tripp Fuller. This is a shorter Q&A episode, where your friendly, local internet theologian answers questions submitted by you.
We got lot of questions about evil, suffering, and divine power. There is the classic philosophical question about evil, and then there is the theological question about evil. How do you even begin to answer these questions? do you deny the goodness of God? do you deny the reality of evil? or do we reject God's divine omnipotence?
But before he even gets to those questions, Tripp address the two trajectories in the questions asked:
What is scripture's actual answer to question of evil and suffering?
Does doing theodicy even make sense when you look at the history of slavery and racism in America?
Sometimes we answer theological questions in a way that abstracts our lived experience. So Tripp, in this Q&A, wants to affirm the experiences that generate these questions, while also trying to situate them in the broader context of the theological and philosophical questions about evil.