'Alma was a baby on October 7. She knows her father only as a poster'
Feb 10, 2025
auto_awesome
Moshe Lavi, brother-in-law of Israeli hostage Omri Miran, passionately advocates for the plight of hostages. He shares his disappointment with Prime Minister Netanyahu's refusal to meet families, juxtaposed against the backdrop of chilling stories from returning captives. Lavi highlights the urgency for effective negotiations as Miran remains in peril. Delving into the emotional struggles of young children like Alma missing their father, he encapsulates the pain of absence and the relentless hope families cling to amid the turmoil.
The emotional turmoil for families escalates as they grapple with the juxtaposition of celebrating hostages' release while mourning their physical and psychological suffering.
The urgency for a comprehensive hostage release deal grows, as families express skepticism about negotiations' effectiveness and advocate for prioritizing the safety of all remaining hostages.
Deep dives
Emotional Reactions to Hostage Release
The recent release of three hostages from Hamas captivity sparked intense emotions among the Israeli public, transitioning from excitement to horror as the condition of the hostages became apparent. The release, initially celebrated, turned somber when observers noted the marked deterioration in the hostages’ physical appearance, likening them to survivors of concentration camps. This stark contrast affected families of other hostages deeply, evoking fears for their loved ones still held in Gaza, particularly in the case of Omri Miran. As families witnessed the emotional reunions, their hearts were filled with both joy for those reunited and anguish for their remaining loved ones, highlighting the complex emotional landscape of hostage recovery.
The Urgent Quest for Phase Two Negotiations
The upcoming negotiations for the second phase of the hostage release deal are a pressing concern, with the outcome critically linked to the fates of remaining hostages, such as Omri. Family members express skepticism regarding the effectiveness of the negotiators, worrying that discussions may be more about appearance rather than genuine progress. The families urge a shift in focus from a gradual release to a comprehensive deal, advocating for a swift resolution that prioritizes the safety and well-being of all hostages, given the devastating impact of prolonged captivity. The determination to see every hostage released underscores the urgency felt by those whose loved ones are still in captivity, emphasizing the dire humanitarian conditions they face.
The Challenge of Advocacy from Abroad
Advocating for the release of hostages while facing rising anti-Semitism and international disinformation presents unique challenges for families like Moshe Lavi's, especially while navigating political complexities. Being abroad complicates their efforts, as they strive to combat narratives that equate hostages with other prisoners, ensuring the public understands the severity of their plight. Families feel a responsibility to remind policymakers of the dire humanitarian conditions that hostages endure, and they remain committed to engaging with various stakeholders to amplify their message. This dual fight—against the backdrop of a crisis at home and growing sentiments abroad—reinforces their resolve to secure a resolution that prioritizes the safe return of all hostages.
Moshe Lavi, the brother-in-law of Israeli hostage Omri Miran, was one of the activists for the release of the hostages who traveled to Washington D.C. last week during the visit by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. In conversation with Haaretz Podcast host Allison Kaplan Sommer, he says he was disappointed by Netanyahu's refusal to meet with the families in the U.S. capital.
Netanyahu extended his stay in Washington, enjoying his time alongside Donald Trump as the U.S. president announced a plan to take over Gaza. But back home, the country was shocked by the emaciated physical state of returning hostages Or Levy, Ohad Ben-Ami and Eli Sharabi, and their stories of severe abuse at the hands of their Hamas captors.
Miran, who is married to Lavi's sister Lishay and is father to his toddler nieces Ronni and Alma, is slated to be released only in stage two of the current framework and at the moment, Lavi says, "we are not certain that it is going to take place, or will take place soon enough, because the hostages don't have time - they need to be rescued and released as soon as possible."