If you’ve ever wondered why your students can master comprehension skills one week but struggle the next, you’re not alone. Many upper elementary teachers follow a standards-based approach, teaching comprehension skills in isolation. But what if that’s the very thing preventing students from building lasting comprehension? In today’s episode, we’re diving into the biggest mistake teachers make when teaching comprehension—and why shifting your approach can lead to better results.

Too often, comprehension instruction in upper elementary classrooms is structured around a checklist of isolated skills—one week on main idea, another on summarizing, then moving on to character analysis. But is this approach truly helping students become strong, independent readers? The reality is that comprehension isn’t just about mastering individual skills—it’s an outcome that depends on multiple factors, including background knowledge, vocabulary, and fluency. When we focus too heavily on isolated comprehension strategies, we miss the bigger picture of what truly helps students understand and retain what they read.

We’ll break down why teaching comprehension skills in isolation doesn’t lead to lasting comprehension and discuss the key factors that truly impact students’ ability to understand a text. By the end of this episode, you’ll start to see comprehension not as a checklist of strategies but as an outcome—one that requires the right instructional conditions to happen. And if you want to take an even deeper dive into this topic, be sure to join us for our upcoming Unlocking Comprehension workshop this March at stellarteacher.com/workshop.

Join us in the Stellar Literacy Collective Membership: stellarteacher.com/join!

Sign up for my FREE private podcast, the Confident Writer Systems Series, here!

Sign up for my FREE Revision Made Easy email series here!

Follow me on Instagram @thestellarteachercompany.

To check out all of the resources from this episode, head to the show notes: https://www.stellarteacher.com/episode244.

Miscalculations in the Court of Richard II (with Helen Castor)