George H.W. Bush banning broccoli from Air Force One sparks a national frenzy and potentially impacts his presidency. The controversy surrounding his dislike of broccoli leads to media involvement, reactions from the broccoli industry, and speculation about his true reasons. Despite the negative attention, Barbara Bush's love for broccoli and a White House ceremony help end the story positively.
Former President George H.W. Bush's humility and authenticity were seen as endearing qualities, despite his limitations as a communicator.
The broccoli controversy showcased Bush's determination to stand his ground on even seemingly insignificant issues, resulting in a surge in sales for the broccoli industry.
Deep dives
George H.W. Bush's Humility and Insecurity as President
In an interview with White House correspondent Ken Walsh, former President George H.W. Bush's humility and insecurity during his presidency were highlighted. Despite following the charismatic Ronald Reagan, Bush acknowledged his limitations as a communicator. He was not interested in stagecraft and wanted to be a low-key chief executive. However, this led to frustration for journalists like Walsh as the Bush administration did not generate many stories. Despite the challenges, Bush's humility and authenticity were seen as endearing qualities.
The Broccoli Controversy and Bush's Hatred for the Vegetable
A trivial yet significant incident that occurred during the Bush administration was the broccoli controversy. President Bush's strong dislike for broccoli was well-known, and he made it clear that he would not eat it. A story broke out about Bush banning broccoli on Airforce One, sparking a national frenzy. The incident highlighted Bush's firm stance on the vegetable and his unwillingness to give in to the pressure. Although the broccoli controversy may have seemed trivial, it showcased Bush's determination to stand his ground on even seemingly insignificant issues.
Impact of the Broccoli Story
The broccoli story, while seemingly trivial, had a significant impact on the public and the broccoli industry. The story garnered immense media coverage, with various reactions from commentators and individuals across the country. While some supported Bush's hatred for broccoli, others rallied behind the vegetable, emphasizing its health benefits and delicious taste. Ultimately, the broccoli industry experienced a surge in sales and received approximately $100 million in free publicity. The incident demonstrated the power of a seemingly minor controversy in capturing public attention and influencing opinions.
Broccoli Truck and White House Ceremony
To challenge President Bush's hatred for broccoli, a truckload of broccoli was sent to Washington, D.C. by a produce company. The 10-ton shipment was met with significant media coverage and public interest. Despite Bush's refusal to eat broccoli, a ceremony was organized on the South Lawn of the White House, where Barbara Bush, who enjoyed the vegetable, accepted the donation. This event highlighted the enthusiasm and support for broccoli among Americans, and the ceremony offered a platform for discussion on the importance and value of healthy eating.
In March 1990, a story broke that shocked the nation: George H.W. Bush had banned broccoli from Air Force One. The frenzy that came next would change the fate of a vegetable—and maybe even alter the course of a presidency.
This episode was written by Olivia Briley and Josh Levin, One Year’s editorial director. One Year’s senior producer is Evan Chung.
This episode was produced by Olivia Briley and Kelly Jones.
It was edited by Joel Meyer and Evan Chung.
Derek John is Slate’s executive producer of narrative podcasts.
Merritt Jacob is senior technical director.
Join Slate Plus to get a special behind-the-scenes conversation at the end of our season about how we put together our 1990 stories. Slate Plus members also get to listen to all Slate podcasts without any ads.