Young leaders gather in the 80s and 90s, sparking a reconfiguration of Christianity. The influence of Leadership Network on church growth strategies is explored. Personal experiences of feeling called into ministry and meeting Doug Padgett are shared. The emergence of the vocal Emerging Church Movement in the late 90s is discussed. The impact of Willow Creek on the formation of a movement and the Church within a Church model is examined. The origins and assumptions of ministry to Gen Xers are explored. Authentic and unorthodox church gatherings are highlighted. Crowdfunding and community support are encouraged.
The emergence of the Emerging Church Movement was influenced by the rise of youth ministry and the tension between authentic faith experiences and traditional church expectations.
The Emerging Church Movement embraced individualism, pluralism, and engagement with philosophical ideas, challenging the traditional paradigms of truth and knowledge in the church.
Deep dives
Exploring New Approaches to Church
In the mid-90s, there was a growing realization among church leaders that traditional approaches to church were not resonating with the younger generation. The rise of youth ministry in the 80s and 90s brought about a radical shift in how young people were engaged in church, from playing games and using contemporary music to creating a more informal and authentic environment. However, as these young people grew older, they were often expected to conform to the more traditional practices and structures of the church, which led to a tension between the desire for a more relational and authentic faith experience and the expectations of the church.
The Shifting Paradigm of Faith
During this time, there was a broader cultural context that fueled the emergence of the church movement. The 80s and 90s saw the rise of evangelical Christianity, fueled by a focus on political conservatism, fundamentalist beliefs, and a desire for increased organizational influence. However, as younger generations came of age, they were not following the same religious trends as the baby boomers. Many Gen Xers were questioning traditional beliefs and seeking a faith that was personal, individualized, and did not conform to the monolithic youth culture promoted by the church. This led to a deep restlessness and a search for spirituality that was authentic and tailored to their own experiences.
Questioning Assumptions and Exploring New Ideas
The emerging church movement was characterized by a willingness to question the assumptions and practices of traditional Christianity. This included open discussions and debate on topics such as the age of the Earth and salvation, where opposing viewpoints were presented and individuals were encouraged to engage in thoughtful dialogue. The movement sought to create spaces where authenticity and pluralism were valued, allowing individuals to explore their own spiritual journeys without the pressure to conform to a specific belief system. This emphasis on individualized faith and a rejection of a one-size-fits-all approach to Christianity set the stage for the emergence of new ideas and practices in the church.
The Impact of Cultural and Intellectual Shifts
The emerging church movement coincided with broader cultural and intellectual shifts, such as the postmodernism and poststructuralism movements. These shifts challenged the prevailing paradigms of truth, knowledge, and authority, and had a profound impact on how individuals engaged with religion and spirituality. The movement recognized that the traditional ways of understanding and practicing Christianity did not resonate with the changing cultural landscape and the new epistemological frameworks emerging in society. Instead, it sought to rearticulate and re-embody the faith in ways that aligned with these shifts, embracing diversity, individualism, and a deep engagement with philosophical and theological ideas. The tension between the pragmatic approaches of traditional church growth movements and the deeper questions about the nature of faith and the message of the gospel became a central issue for the emerging church movement.
The Emerging Church Movement did not come from nowhere. It sprung from a history that included the Jesus Movement, the Seeker Sensitive Megachurch Movement, and a revolution in youth ministry. In this episode, hosts Tony Jones and Tripp Fuller talk about what was happening in the 1980s and 1990s in the American church that laid the groundwork for the ECM. Their guests include Danielle Shroyer, Brad Cecil, Tim Conder, Gerardo Marti, and Doug Pagitt.
Emerged is a crowdfunded project. If you join, you’ll have access to extra material, ad-free episodes, private livestreams with the hosts and guests, and an array of gifts at various levels of partnership. Learn more and join at EmergedPodcast.com.