Selena Gomez, the talented pop star and executive producer of the Netflix series, joins researchers Eilish Gilligan and audio producer Ruby Hall. They dive into the cultural impact of '13 Reasons Why,' discussing its controversial themes of suicide, bullying, and mental health. The trio explores how Hannah Baker's story ignited crucial conversations among teens and parents alike. They also tackle the balance between dark humor and sensitivity while reflecting on the show's lasting legacy in reshaping narratives around serious societal issues.
The adaptation of '13 Reasons Why' aimed to spark vital conversations about mental health and the challenges faced by teenagers today.
Despite its good intentions, the series faced criticism for romanticizing suicide and oversimplifying complex mental health issues, raising safety concerns.
Deep dives
Cultural Impact and Controversy of 13 Reasons Why
The novel '13 Reasons Why' was published in 2007, quickly becoming a cultural phenomenon. It tells the story of Hannah Baker, who leaves behind audio tapes detailing the reasons for her suicide, revealing the impact of bullying and trauma on her life. The adaptation into a Netflix series in 2017, produced by Selena Gomez, sparked extensive discussions about mental health, suicide, and youth experiences. However, it also drew significant criticism for its graphic depiction of sensitive topics, raising concerns among parents and mental health professionals.
The Role of Media in Addressing Mental Health
The series aimed to initiate important conversations about mental health, tackling issues like sexual assault and bullying while portraying the harsh realities faced by teenagers. Despite its good intentions, many critics argued that it oversimplified the complexities of mental health issues and romanticized suicide. Reviews highlighted the narrative's problematic elements, with the show's depiction of Hannah's struggles seen as both a tool for awareness and a potential trigger for vulnerable viewers. Critics pointed out a dissonance in the show's approach, balancing educational representation with sensationalized drama that may not effectively serve its intended purpose.
Viewer Reception and Mixed Messages
Upon its release, '13 Reasons Why' recorded significant viewership, illustrating its impact on youth culture. A follow-up study showed that many teens felt more comfortable discussing tough topics after watching the show, suggesting a level of positive reception. However, multiple reports indicated that the series created a complicated narrative, leading to misconceptions about the finality of suicide and the perceived effectiveness of seeking help from adults. The show's portrayal, particularly in graphic scenes involving Hannah's suicide, drew backlash and ultimately led to Netflix revising its content to promote viewer safety.
Legacy and Final Reception of the Series
As the series progressed through multiple seasons, the initial fervor dimmed, with critics pointing to a decline in quality and a shift toward dramatic storytelling. Despite the discussions it sparked around mental health, there were ongoing debates about its lasting impact on viewers, especially regarding representation of suicide and mental health crises. The eventual decision to remove the graphic suicide scene indicated a recognition of the concerns surrounding its depiction. Ultimately, '13 Reasons Why' remains a contentious part of media history, exemplifying the challenges in balancing sensitivity and storytelling within popular culture.
In October 2015, Netflix purchased a 13-episode series adaptation of 13 Reasons Why, executive-produced by none other than then-24-year-old pop star Selena Gomez. Today, we’re deep-diving how it all played out.
This episode was researched by Eilish Gilligan and audio produced by Ruby Hall.
Big thanks to ING for making this episode possible. With ING’s Orange Everyday and Savings Maximiser, you’re all set. Remember, these steps can help you make bank the ING way. Ready to get started? Just search “ING Make Bank” and you’re on your way.
(The legal stuff: This figure is based on customer data between April 2023 to April 2024. The potential benefits of these two products depend on variable factors and eligibility criteria. This is not financial advice and ING recommends you seek independent financial advice. T&Cs apply. ING ABN 24 000 893 292 and AFSL 229823.)
Want to support our show? Clicking ‘follow’ on Apple and Spotify is the best way to do that, and we're super grateful to anyone who leaves a five-star review while they're at it. Also! An old-fashioned 'Tell a Friend In Real Life' is equally appreciated.