The podcast dives into the impact of the Trump administration on scientific agencies, highlighting the drastic policy changes and communication blackouts. Personal stories reveal the struggles researchers face amid funding uncertainties and staffing losses. Chaos at the NIH and challenges within the CDC paint a disturbing picture of instability in public health response. The discussion raises alarms about the future of science, focusing on budget cuts and their implications for upcoming scientists and the U.S.'s role in global research.
The Trump administration's executive orders caused significant disruptions in scientific institutions, leading to communication blackouts and funding restrictions that hindered vital research initiatives.
Amidst heightened staff anxiety and firings, the CDC and NIH faced challenges that raised concerns about the credibility and future of U.S. scientific progress.
Deep dives
Impact of Executive Orders on Scientific Institutions
The Trump administration implemented measures that significantly affected scientific institutions by instituting communication blackouts and restricting funding. These actions led to the National Institutes of Health (NIH) and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) experiencing heightened confusion and fear, as employees could not communicate with external stakeholders. As a result, NIH announced a controversial cap on indirect costs that was met with strong opposition from the research community, as it threatened to cripple vital medical research. Throughout these changes, many researchers expressed concern about the long-term implications for U.S. science and how such measures could dismantle over decades of established scientific progress.
Challenges Faced by the CDC
The CDC faced notable disruptions due to the executive orders, leading to communication freezes and arbitrary firings, which significantly hampered its ability to respond to health crises. During this tumultuous period, crucial data and resources were removed from the CDC's website, further complicating public health efforts. Although some key personnel were allowed to return, the lingering effects of the firings created a sense of mistrust towards the data shared by the agency. As the CDC attempted to manage various active outbreak responses, staff morale remained low with ongoing concerns about job security.
The National Science Foundation's Transformation
The National Science Foundation (NSF) experienced a dramatic shift, including the freezing of grant reviews and funding due to the need to align with new executive orders focusing on diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI). This freeze caused financial distress for researchers reliant on NSF funds, who struggled to cover basic living expenses. Although grant payouts eventually resumed, apprehension remained regarding the ongoing DEI reviews that could jeopardize many existing grants. The new funding strategies proposed by the administration prompted fears about stifling scientific innovation, as researchers worried that the focus on DEI could detract from the quality of scientific inquiry.
In its first 50 days, the Trump administration made sweeping changes to scientific arms of the government like the Department of Health and Human Services, which oversees the National Institutes of Health, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and the Food and Drug Administration. The president issued executive orders to terminate all work that was related to DEI, environmental justice and gender inclusivity. In response, research was halted and thousands of people were fired — some of which was reversed. It's a lot to keep track of, so we called in reinforcements. Here to recount it all and analyze what these ongoing changes mean for the future of scientific research in the United States are NPR science correspondents Rob Stein, Pien Huang and Jonathan Lambert.
Want to hear more about policy changes affecting science? Let us know by emailing shortwave@npr.org! We're also always open to other story ideas you have.
Listen to every episode of Short Wave sponsor-free and support our work at NPR by signing up for Short Wave+ at plus.npr.org/shortwave.