What Next TBD: Have Algorithms Ruined Our Culture?
Jan 21, 2024
auto_awesome
Kyle Chayka, author of Filterworld, discusses the impact of algorithms on culture and the homogenization of content. Topics include the rise of airspace design, the influence of algorithms on aesthetic preferences, the connection between auto-fiction and Instagram, and the anxiety caused by algorithmic manipulation.
Algorithms have created a filtered world that shapes our tastes and preferences, influencing everything from coffee shops to our online experiences.
The shift from chronological feeds to algorithmic recommendations on social media platforms has led to content conformity and pressure on creators to produce popular, rather than diverse, content.
Deep dives
The Influence of Algorithms on Culture
The podcast episode explores the concept of Filter World, a term coined by Kyle Chica, a staff writer at The New Yorker, to describe the homogenization of culture driven by algorithms. Chica discusses how coffee shops, co-working spaces, and even our online experiences have become part of this filtered world, shaped by algorithms that recommend and prioritize certain content. He highlights the impact of algorithmic recommendations on our tastes and preferences, as well as the challenges faced by creators who must tailor their work to fit the algorithmic feed. Chica also explores the anxiety and lack of agency individuals experience in the face of these powerful algorithms.
The Shift from Chronological Feeds to Algorithmic Recommendations
Chica traces the transition from chronological feeds to algorithmic recommendations on social media platforms like Facebook and Instagram. He explains how this shift, which occurred around 2015-2016, led to content being sorted and recommended based on algorithms rather than user preferences. Chica raises concerns about the impact of algorithmic filtering on culture and taste, as it favors easily digestible and sharable content rather than challenging or diverse perspectives. He also discusses the pressure on creators to conform their work to what the algorithm deems popular, potentially distorting their creative practices.
Algorithmic Anxiety and the Need for Regulation
Chica explores the concept of algorithmic anxiety and the unknowability of how algorithms shape our online experiences. He highlights how users constantly navigate the influence of algorithmic recommendations and face challenges in expressing their preferences or changing the algorithms' behavior. Chica argues for the need for regulatory measures that give users more control over their data, the ability to opt out of surveillance, and the option to opt out of algorithmic feeds. He suggests that increased competition and breaking down monopolies in the tech industry would lead to a wider diversity of experiences and a more sustainable ecosystem for culture and creativity.
If you enjoy this show, please consider signing up for Slate Plus. Slate Plus members get benefits like zero ads on any Slate podcast, bonus episodes of shows like Slow Burn and Dear Prudence—and you’ll be supporting the work we do here on What Next TBD. Sign up now at slate.com/whatnextplus to help support our work.