James O’Brien on the media figures who “broke Britain”
Nov 16, 2023
auto_awesome
LBC broadcaster and author James O'Brien discusses media figures who 'broke Britain', including Paul Dacre, Rupert Murdoch, and Andrew Neil. Topics include David Cameron's return, lack of media accountability, manipulation by powerful figures, and the impact on democracy. O'Brien reflects on opinionated broadcasting and offers advice to young journalists.
Rupert Murdoch, Paul Dacre, and Andrew Neil have played a significant role in eroding British society through the spread of tabloid sensibilities and biased journalism.
The Daily Mail, under the editorship of Paul Dacre, has fueled fear and polarization by creating a narrative of victimhood and scapegoating.
James O'Brien emphasizes the importance of evidence-based opinionated broadcasting and encourages diverse opinions and listener interaction in the media landscape.
Deep dives
James O'Brien criticizes media figures who broke Britain
James O'Brien discusses the role of media figures like Rupert Murdoch, Paul Dacre, and Andrew Neil in what he sees as the erosion of British society. He highlights how Murdoch's media empire has spread tabloid sensibilities and subverted the truth. O'Brien also criticizes Dacre for weaponizing immigration and creating a narrative of victimhood, and he questions Neil's role in providing a platform for right-wing rhetoric. He argues that these figures contribute to a toxic media environment and the decline of balanced journalism.
O'Brien calls out the influence of the Daily Mail
O'Brien examines the power and influence of the Daily Mail and its editor's influence on setting the tone of public discourse. He criticizes the paper for creating a narrative that portrays the readers as under siege, fueling fear and othering. He believes that the Daily Mail's relentless focus on victimhood and scapegoating has contributed to a polarized and toxic public discourse.
Opinionated broadcasting and the difference with GB News
O'Brien discusses his own opinionated broadcasting on LBC, highlighting that he backs up his opinions with evidence and engages with callers who can challenge him. In contrast, he questions the lack of depth and justification behind some opinionated broadcasting on GB News. He also points out the importance of listener interaction and a diversity of opinions in the broadcasting landscape.
The comeback of David Cameron and entitlement in politics
O'Brien criticizes David Cameron as an emblem of a class system that creates entitlement and breeds politicians who believe they are born to rule. He argues that Cameron's handling of Brexit and the current political landscape demonstrate his arrogance and complacency. O'Brien questions whether Cameron recognizes his responsibility for the political challenges the UK currently faces.
Advice for aspiring journalists
O'Brien advises young journalists to consider building their own platforms and brands in the current media landscape. He encourages them not to be deterred by compromises they may have to make initially and highlights the opportunities afforded by the digital revolution. He emphasizes the need to stay curious and challenges traditional expectations of joining established media organizations.
Alan and Lionel speak to LBC broadcaster and author James O’Brien, who takes aim at Daily Mail chief Paul Dacre, news mogul Rupert Murdoch and journalist, broadcaster and editor Andrew Neil—three media figures he includes in his book about the people he thinks “broke Britain”.
O’Brien also reflects on David Cameron’s return to frontline politics and discusses his own version of opinionated political broadcasting.
About Prospect
Prospect brings rigorously fact-checked analysis, ideas and perspectives to the big topics the world is grappling with. In addition to being the UK’s leading monthly current affairs magazine, Prospect publishes daily commentary and analysis online. Even more discussion about the ideas that matter is available in our growing range of newsletters and podcasts, the most recent of which is Media Confidential.
Black Friday offer: Enjoy 50% off an annual digital subscription and receive full access to rigorously fact-checked, truly independent analysis and perspectives.