Ancient Faith Today Live Answering the Claims of a Former Priest
Jun 18, 2025
Joshua Sherman, a frequent voice on faith discussions, joins Fr. Thomas to tackle objections from a former Orthodox priest. They dive into the necessity of defending Orthodoxy, addressing misconceptions about law and gospel while highlighting the importance of tradition. The pair explores the complexities of atonement theories, contrasting Orthodox views with Protestant interpretations. Sherman emphasizes the transformative power of scripture and the sacred responsibility of the priesthood, encouraging a sincere spiritual commitment.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Require Stability for Priests
- Priests must exhibit stability and clarity in faith before ordination for lifelong commitment.
- Avoid ordaining those with fluctuating beliefs or doubts to preserve church integrity.
Flaws in Law-Gospel Divide
- The law-gospel distinction is an overreaction rooted in Lutheranism’s reading of Paul's writings.
- The gospel encompasses judgment and grace together, not a rigid separation of law and good news.
Gospel Is Comprehensive Teaching
- The gospel in scripture is not a single formula but an entire body of teaching about Christ.
- Reducing it to a slogan misunderstands its richness and depth in scripture and tradition.
