Sam Harris speaks with philosopher Peter Singer about the moral status of non-human animals, speciesism, and the scale of animal suffering. They also discuss conscientious omnivores, animal experimentation, and concerns about Effective Altruism. Singer's influential book 'Animal Liberation' is explored, as well as the comparative nature of human suffering and the work of philosopher Derek Parfit. They touch on objective morality and delve into Buddhist ethics and contemporary issues with a female Buddhist monastic.
The moral implications of animal experimentation and mistreatment are discussed, highlighting the need to minimize animal suffering.
The concept of speciesism is examined, challenging the notion that species membership should determine moral value.
Peter Singer's book 'Animal Liberation Now' explores the moral status of non-human animals and the importance of addressing the scale of animal suffering caused by human activities.
The podcast discusses effective altruism and the need for talented individuals to directly work for organizations that help people in need, expanding the concept beyond earning to give.
Deep dives
The Ethical Treatment of Animals
Animal experimentation and the mistreatment of animals for various purposes, such as farming, is discussed. The podcast explores the moral implications and justification for these practices, raising questions about the moral hierarchy between humans and non-human animals. It also delves into the potential alternatives to animal experimentation and the importance of minimizing animal suffering.
The Limits of Speciesism
The concept of speciesism is examined, which asserts that humans often prioritize their own species over others, leading to the mistreatment of animals. The podcast challenges the notion that species membership should determine moral value and highlights the need to consider the suffering and well-being of all sentient beings, regardless of their species.
Animal Liberation in Ethics
The podcast delves into Peter Singer's book, 'Animal Liberation Now,' and its impact on the animal welfare movement. It discusses the moral status of non-human animals, the ethics of animal experimentation, and the need to recognize and address the immense scale of animal suffering caused by human activities, such as factory farming.
Controversies in Effective Altruism
The podcast touches on the concept of effective altruism and its role in guiding philanthropic decisions. It explores criticisms and misconceptions surrounding the movement, including the perception of virtue signaling and concerns about prioritizing earning potential in order to donate large sums of money. The Sam Bankman-Fried case is mentioned as an example of the challenges and controversies within the effective altruism community.
The importance of giving: Missed opportunities and lessons learned
The podcast episode discusses the missed opportunity of a billionaire who could have made a significant positive impact on the world through charitable giving, but instead made risky investments and misused client funds. The episode emphasizes the importance of philanthropy and highlights the need for effective altruism, which goes beyond earning to give. It suggests that talented individuals should consider working directly for organizations that help people in need and focus on making a tangible difference, rather than relying solely on financial contributions.
The danger of departing from ethical rules and conduct
The podcast episode explores the consequences of departing from accepted rules of good conduct in the financial sector, using the example of a hedge fund manager who engaged in risky behavior and misused client funds. It highlights the need for individuals to abide by ethical standards and not take shortcuts, even when pursuing high-risk investment strategies or opportunities. The episode emphasizes the importance of adhering to the established rules and duties in order to avoid severe consequences and reputational damage.
A balanced approach to effective altruism
The podcast episode presents a critique of an overemphasis on earning to give in the effective altruism movement. It suggests that effective altruism should encompass a broader range of actions and strategies to create a positive impact. The episode discusses the value of talented individuals working directly for organizations that help people in extreme poverty or working to achieve important goals in various fields such as healthcare, agriculture, and politics. It emphasizes the need for balance in addressing both immediate needs and long-term risks, including potential global catastrophes and maximization of human well-being.
Sam Harris speaks with Peter Singer about important problems in ethics. They discuss his career as a philosopher, the moral status of non-human animals, the ethics of moral hierarchies, speciesism, the scale of animal suffering, conscientious omnivores, animal experimentation, the tragic case of Sam Bankman-Fried, concerns about Effective Altruism, the problems with focusing on existential risk, the comparative nature of human suffering, the work of Derek Parfit, objective morality, and other topics.
Peter Singer, dubbed “the world’s most influential living philosopher” by The New Yorker, has written, co-authored, edited, or co-edited more than 50 books in over 25 languages, including Practical Ethics, Writings on an Ethical Life, The Life You Can Save, and more. His 1975 book Animal Liberation is often credited with starting the modern animal rights movement. His TED Talk has over 2.25 million views.
Learning how to train your mind is the single greatest investment you can make in life. That’s why Sam Harris created the Waking Up app. From rational mindfulness practice to lessons on some of life’s most important topics, join Sam as he demystifies the practice of meditation and explores the theory behind it.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
