The Decibel Segregation of child inmates being challenged in landmark lawsuit
Sep 8, 2025
Globe reporter Robyn Doolittle sheds light on the harrowing realities of youth inmates in solitary confinement in Manitoba. She discusses the landmark class action lawsuit challenging these inhumane practices, alleging violations of the Canadian Charter. The conversation dives into the detrimental psychological effects of segregation on young detainees and examines the broader legal implications for reforming juvenile justice policies. Doolittle also draws alarming parallels with U.S. cases, advocating for urgent changes to protect vulnerable children.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Devon's Early Segregation Trauma
- Devon Daniels was first put in segregation at 14 and estimates about 15 placements before age 18.
- He describes the experience as traumatizing and life-changing, stealing part of his innocence and safety.
A Cell Described As A Dungeon
- Devon describes cells as tiny, with lights on 24/7 and a concrete slab for a bed.
- He remembers the smell of piss, sweat and excrement smeared on walls and crippling boredom while staring at the wall.
Solitary Versus Segregation Debate
- Solitary is defined as confinement without meaningful human contact for 22+ hours; Manitoba denies its segregation meets that bar.
- Science shows solitary causes severe mental harm, and experts say effects are amplified in developing youth brains.