

Critics hated 'The Phantom Menace.' It might be time to reconsider
7 snips May 10, 2024
In this conversation with Eric Schwartzel, a film industry journalist and author specializing in Star Wars, the discussion dives into the 25-year journey of 'The Phantom Menace.' Initially met with disappointment, they explore how perceptions have shifted among fans over time. Schwartzel delves into the ambitious technological innovations and the mixed legacy of characters like Jar Jar Binks. The talk highlights the film’s profound impact on the Star Wars fandom, igniting passionate debates and reshaping how enthusiasts engage with the franchise.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Trailer Hype
- People bought tickets to Meet Joe Black just to see The Phantom Menace trailer.
- This created box office bumps for unrelated movies.
Polarized Reactions
- Initial fan and critic reactions to The Phantom Menace were extremely polarized.
- While some fans displayed immense excitement, critics like Tom Shales and Bob Mondello expressed strong disapproval.
Fan Disappointment
- The Phantom Menace faced backlash for various reasons including a nine-year-old Darth Vader and discussions of taxes.
- This led to a loud wave of disappointment among fans.