The Problem with Pronatalism

Jun 26, 2025

Ryan Turnipseed, a graduate student in entrepreneurship at Oklahoma State University and summer fellow at the Mises Institute, dives into the complexities of pronatalism. He critiques the economic arguments that suggest higher birth rates boost national security and economic stability. Turnipseed emphasizes the importance of viewing economic systems as collective human actions, advocating for personal fulfillment over mere growth. He also discusses how a declining population could potentially enhance productivity, challenge state policies, and value traditional family structures.

Ask episode

AI Snips

Chapters

Books

Transcript

Episode notes

INSIGHT

What Is Pronatalism?

Pronatalism is the idea that people should have more children to avoid negative societal outcomes.
It has a mix of proponents, from religious conservatives to figures like Elon Musk, with varied motivations.

INSIGHT

Families vs. The State

Families are the fundamental institution predating the state and essential to social stability.
The state often undermines families to create more controllable, atomized societies.

ANECDOTE

Eclectic Faces of Pronatalism

The pronatalist movement includes eclectic and often off-putting figures like the neo-Puritan Collins couple.
This odd image weakens the movement’s credibility despite its noble goal.

Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode

Get the app

A History of Economic Thought

Murray Rothbard

Murray Rothbard's "A History of Economic Thought" provides a comprehensive overview of the evolution of economic ideas from ancient Greece to the 20th century. The book delves into the contributions of various schools of thought, including the classical, mercantilist, and Austrian schools. Rothbard critically examines the assumptions and methodologies of each school, highlighting their strengths and weaknesses. He emphasizes the importance of understanding the historical context of economic theories to better grasp their relevance and limitations. The book is a valuable resource for students and scholars of economics, offering a nuanced and insightful perspective on the development of economic thought. It challenges conventional narratives and encourages critical thinking about economic principles.

Human action

A Treatise on Economics

Ludwig von Mises

Human Action is Ludwig von Mises' magnum opus, where he defends an a priori foundation for praxeology and methodological individualism. The book argues that the free-market economy outdistances any government-planned system and serves as the foundation of civilization. Mises explains complex market phenomena as the outcomes of countless conscious, purposive actions and choices of individuals. He critiques government attempts to regulate and control economic activities, emphasizing the futility and counter-productiveness of such interventions. The book is a systematic treatment of the whole body of social and economic relations, integrating various economic problems into a comprehensive system[2][4][5].

Man, economy, and state

Murray Rothbard

Man, Economy, and State is a seminal work in Austrian economics, written by Murray N. Rothbard. The book develops the entire body of economic theory step-by-step, starting from incontestable axioms and addressing complex issues such as business cycle theory and monopoly theory. It also includes a critique of government intervention in markets, which is further elaborated in the companion text, Power and Market. Rothbard's work is known for its clear and rigorous presentation of economic principles, emphasizing the importance of individual action and the free market. The book is considered a modern classic and ranks alongside Ludwig von Mises's Human Action as a cornerstone of the Austrian School of economics.