In a thought-provoking discussion, Daniel Markovits, a Yale law professor and author of The Meritocracy Trap, explores the pitfalls of meritocracy. He argues that instead of fostering equal opportunity, it entrenches societal inequalities, creating a new caste system. The conversation delves into the impact of the education system on wealth disparity and the challenges faced by the shrinking middle class. Markovits also critiques the elite's reluctance to support wealth redistribution, emphasizing the need for fair taxation and shared responsibility in addressing systemic inequalities.
58:59
forum Ask episode
web_stories AI Snips
view_agenda Chapters
menu_book Books
auto_awesome Transcript
info_circle Episode notes
insights INSIGHT
Meritocracy's Downside
Meritocracy, intended to promote equality, now hinders it by favoring the elite.
The elite's children receive superior education, perpetuating their advantage.
insights INSIGHT
U.S. Inequality
U.S. inequality resembles India's more than France's, with rising wealth concentration.
The richest 1% earn double their 1960 share, while poverty has decreased.
insights INSIGHT
Labor vs. Capital
Unlike Piketty's focus on capital, Markovits argues that labor is the primary source of top 1% income.
The wealthy now work longer hours than the less affluent, a reversal of historical trends.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
In *The Meritocracy Trap*, Daniel Markovits argues that meritocracy, rather than being a virtuous and efficient system, has become the single greatest obstacle to equal opportunities in America. The book exposes how meritocracy breeds inequality, ensnares even those at the top in intense work regimes, and prevents social mobility. Markovits, drawing from his extensive experience at elite universities, provides a comprehensive critique of the meritocratic system, highlighting its corrosive effects on both the middle class and the elite. He also discusses the need for a new perspective that moves beyond the current meritocratic narrative to achieve a more equitable society.
Capital in the Twenty-First Century
Thomas Piketty
In this book, Thomas Piketty examines the historical dynamics of wealth and income inequality from the 18th century to the present. He argues that when the rate of return on capital exceeds the rate of economic growth, it leads to a concentration of wealth and significant social and economic instability. Piketty's analysis is based on extensive historical and comparative data from over twenty countries, challenging the notion that free market capitalism naturally reduces inequality. He proposes a global system of progressive wealth taxes to mitigate these inequalities and protect democratic values. The book is a groundbreaking work that reorients our understanding of economic history and the inherent contradictions of capitalism[1][4][5].
Sam Harris speaks with Daniel Markovits about the problems with meritocracy. They discuss the nature of inequality in the United States, the disappearance of the leisure class, the difference between labor and capital as sources of inequality, the way the education system amplifies inequality, the shrinking middle class, deaths of despair, differing social norms among the elite and the working class, the ethics of taxation, scales of philanthropy, universal basic income, the need for a wealth tax, the relationship between meritocracy and political polarization, the illusion of earned advantages, and other topics.
If the Making Sense podcast logo in your player is BLACK, you can SUBSCRIBE to gain access to all full-length episodes at samharris.org/subscribe.
Making Sense with Sam Harris 
