Peter Roberts, an expert in military concepts and warfare, joins US military theorist Amos Fox to discuss the evolution of military strategies. They explore the tension between historical doctrines like maneuver warfare and the practical realities of modern conflicts, particularly urban warfare. The conversation reveals the confusion within military branches on these topics and critiques the over-reliance on maneuver tactics. They advocate for a more adaptable approach, emphasizing the importance of integrating diverse strategies to navigate the complexities of contemporary combat.
Maneuver warfare emphasizes psychological shock and mobility, yet its application often defaults to positional tactics in urban conflict.
The debate between futurist and realist perspectives highlights the need for military doctrine to evolve and incorporate diverse warfare strategies.
Deep dives
Understanding Maneuver Warfare
Maneuver warfare seeks to achieve decisive battle with a focus on psychological shock, aiming to paralyze the enemy's will to fight. This tactical approach emphasizes the combination of mobility and firepower to create a relative advantage over adversaries. Historical examples, such as Hannibal's double envelopment at the Battle of Cannae, illustrate the effectiveness of maneuver warfare but also highlight the confusion surrounding its definition. As maneuver warfare evolved, it came to be viewed as both a method of warfare and a broader strategic concept, complicating its practical application in modern conflicts.
The Dichotomy of Western War Narratives
The Western Way of War is characterized by a dissonance between its narrative-driven ideals and its reality on the battlefield. While the conventional narrative emphasizes precision and maneuver, the practical application often defaults to positional and attrition-based tactics, especially in urban warfare scenarios. This disconnect is evident in recent conflicts, where military forces have engaged in prolonged house-to-house fighting rather than employing the anticipated maneuver strategies. As a result, the ingrained beliefs about maneuver have overshadowed the realities of combat, leading to an incomplete understanding of alternative approaches.
Positional Warfare in Current Conflicts
Contemporary conflicts showcase a significant reliance on positional warfare, particularly when engaging non-state actors who leverage urban environments to negate the advantages of stronger military forces. Historical battles such as Mosul and Marawi exemplify this tactic, where combatants use the inherent challenges of urban landscapes to offset technological superiority. Rather than executing clean, maneuver-based tactics, forces often find themselves entrenched in brutal attritional campaigns that result in high collateral damage and prolonged engagements. This shift towards positional warfare illustrates the necessity for military doctrine to adapt and acknowledge the utility of various strategies beyond merely maneuver.
The Future of Military Doctrine
The discourse surrounding the Western Way of War increasingly centers on the struggle between futurist and realist perspectives in military theory. Futurists advocate for advanced technological and maneuver-centric approaches, while realists highlight the importance of adapting to current combat environments, often boiling down to positional strategies. This ongoing debate underscores the need for a comprehensive understanding of how these elements can coexist in military operations. Ultimately, the evolution of military doctrine must accommodate the effectiveness of various warfighting strategies, recognizing that positional warfare retains a vital role in achieving tactical and strategic success.
Manoeuvre warfare, the manoeuvrist approach, and manoeuverism as military concepts have been revered by Western militaries for half a century, while their lesser-known brethren concepts such as positional and attrition warfare have long been forgotten. Peter Roberts and Amos Fox, a US military theorist, reflect on contemporary conflict against these paradigms and draw some interesting and unexpected conclusions.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode