The Andrew Klavan Show Are Movie Remakes Better Than Originals?
Jul 11, 2025
The debate over movie remakes versus originals heats up! Iconic films like 'Ocean's Eleven' and 'True Grit' are scrutinized, revealing that some remakes outshine the originals. Classic films are compared, including Hitchcock's works, showcasing timeless charm against modern takes. The unique strengths of titles like 'Scarface' reveal how cultural context shapes legacies. Ghost story adaptations are also dissected, with a preference for the original 'The Woman in Black,' highlighting Hollywood's remake fatigue. Get ready for a cinematic showdown!
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Ocean's Eleven: Remake Beats Original
- The 1960 Ocean's Eleven with the Rat Pack is bad despite its fun atmosphere.
- The 2001 Soderbergh remake is much tighter and superior in storytelling and acting.
True Grit Remake Outshines Original
- The 2010 True Grit remake by the Coen brothers is far superior to the 1969 original.
- John Wayne's old-style movies are better in black and white but don't compare favorably to the remake.
Original Hitchcock is Darker
- The original Hitchcock's The Man Who Knew Too Much is darker and cooler despite aging.
- The remake with Jimmy Stewart and Doris Day is a fun but simpler thriller with bright Technicolor.
