Tiffany Ng, a culture and tech writer for MIT's Tech Review, dives deep into the world of Spotify's influence on music. She discusses how algorithms shape not only our listening habits but also the way artists create music. The concept of 'algorithmic anxiety' emerges as creators feel pressured to conform to streaming trends. Ng also touches on the intersection of music and fashion, highlighting how social media platforms like TikTok amplify micro-trends. Overall, it's a thought-provoking look at the evolving landscape of music consumption.
Spotify's algorithm, while aiming to broaden users' musical exposure, often restricts diversity and leads to repetitive listening experiences.
Musicians are increasingly facing 'algorithmic anxiety,' forcing them to alter their creative instincts to fit streaming platform expectations.
Deep dives
The Influence of Spotify's Algorithm
Spotify utilizes a sophisticated algorithm that combines both listening data and musical characteristics to curate personalized playlists for users. This algorithm categorizes songs into three buckets: those frequently listened to, songs that are similar, and everything else, significantly shaping a listener's music exposure. Consequently, while services like Discover Weekly aim to broaden musical horizons, they may inadvertently restrict exploration to familiar genres and artists, limiting the diversity of music one encounters. Despite intentions to introduce users to new sounds, the algorithm's tendencies can lead to a repetitive listening experience, which discourages trying unfamiliar styles.
Algorithmic Anxiety Among Musicians
Musicians increasingly experience 'algorithmic anxiety' as they feel pressured to craft their songs in ways that align with what the Spotify algorithm considers favorable for promotion. This phenomenon often results in artists prioritizing catchy hooks and song lengths that cater to streaming platforms over their creative instincts, driven by the potential for viral success. The need to satisfy algorithmic criteria can lead to a homogenization of music, with many artists angling for the same brief moment of exposure rather than focusing on artistic expression. Some artists, like Olivia Rodrigo, even contemplate promotional aspects, such as the likelihood of their music being used in trending TikTok videos while composing their tracks.
Emerging Alternatives to Traditional Music Discovery
As listeners seek to break free from the confines of algorithm-driven music recommendations, alternative platforms and methods for discovering music are gaining popularity. Apps that provide a more randomized and exploratory listening experience are challenging the conventional Spotify model, allowing users to navigate music history or various genres outside their usual preferences. This shift signals a growing desire for a music discovery process that feels less curated and more spontaneous, reminiscent of past practices where personal recommendations and physical music exploration were vital. Ultimately, both users and artists are increasingly recognizing the limitations of algorithms and are calling for a more authentic and varied music experience.
Spotify is shaping listening habits, so much so that musicians are shaping themselves for Spotify. It makes your musical world a little more prescribed, a little smaller.
If it feels like everything’s getting a little stale, how do we get out?
Guest: Tiffany Ng, culture and tech writer.
Want more What Next TBD? Subscribe to Slate Plus to access ad-free listening to the whole What Next family and all your favorite Slate podcasts. Subscribe today on Apple Podcasts by clicking “Try Free” at the top of our show page. Sign up now at slate.com/whatnextplus to get access wherever you listen.