In this podcast, Liz and Caroline discuss the trial of Lucy Letby, a nurse accused of harming babies. They explore the opening statements of the prosecution and defense, highlighting the conflicting narratives. The podcast also touches on the role of media in reporting ongoing trials and the challenges faced in ensuring a fair trial. The upcoming episode is previewed, with sponsors mentioned.
23:21
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
The prosecution accuses Lucy Letby, a nurse, of poisoning and causing harm or death to multiple newborn babies in her care over a period of twelve months.
A post-it note found at Lucy Letby's home containing self-descriptions as 'evil' is used by the prosecution as evidence, while the defense argues that it was an anguished outpouring of fear and despair.
Deep dives
The Allegations Against Lucy Letby
Lucy Letby is on trial for the alleged murder of seven newborn babies and the attempted murder of ten others. The prosecution argues that Letby poisoned, injected air, or overfed the babies, causing them harm or death. The alleged incidents occurred over a twelve-month period when Letby was working on the neo-natal unit of Chester Hospital. The prosecution claims that Letby was the only person working on the night shift, and some attacks allegedly happened during that time when fewer staff and parents were present.
The Opening Statements
The prosecution presented a four-day opening statement, alleging that Letby was the constant presence when the babies died or fell ill. They argued that Letby used various methods to harm the babies, such as injecting them with poison or air, and overfeeding them with milk and fluids. Letby denies all the charges against her, and her defense team maintains that she did not harm any of the babies in her care.
The Yellow Post-it Note
During a search at Lucy Letby's home, a yellow post-it note was found. The note contained self-descriptions as 'evil' and stated that Letby purposefully killed the babies because she felt inadequate. However, Letby's defense argued that the note was an anguished outpouring of fear and despair and not a confession. They claim that Letby wrote the note after being accused of the crimes she vehemently denies committing.
This week, Caroline and Liz begin outside the crown court where Liz goes over the opening statements of both the prosecution and the defence. The prosecution accuse Lucy Letby of being ‘a poisoner’ and ‘constant malevolent presence’ on the unit, while the defence say the case against her is based entirely on coincidence and assumption, describing her as a hard working nurse who only tried to help the babies in her care. We’ll also hear from David Banks, a media law expert, who explains the fine line journalists tread when reporting ongoing trials.