A Christmas Christie for Christmas: The Naughty Donkey by Agatha Christie Mallowan (with bonus rerun of Star Over Bethlehem)
Dec 22, 2023
auto_awesome
This podcast episode covers a range of interesting topics, including a deep dive into Agatha Christie's religious tales, the portrayal of animals in Christian tradition, the exploration of Christie's religious beliefs, the analysis of her short story 'Star Over Bethlehem', and the enduring power of her work. It also focuses on the character Miss Marple and her realistic Christian portrayal, and discusses the different approaches to seeking help from Miss Marple and Poirot.
The short story emphasizes lessons of compassion, humility, and the role of animals in the nativity story.
Mary defies the angel and asserts her faith in God's will, choosing not to exercise God's power.
The star over Bethlehem is revealed to be Lucifer falling from the sky, signaling his return to hell.
The podcast explores the concept of low anthropology, challenging high expectations and highlighting the need for redemption and mercy.
Deep dives
The Naughty Donkey: A Bedtime Story
In this short story, Agatha Christie tells the tale of a very naughty little donkey who finds himself in a stable with an ox and a camel in Bethlehem. The donkey boasts about his abilities, but soon has a change of heart when he witnesses the birth of Jesus. He decides to give himself as a gift to the baby and embarks on a journey with Joseph, Mary, and the baby to Egypt to escape King Herod's soldiers. Along the way, the donkey has a vision of Jesus' future, seeing the crucifixion and understanding the sacrifice Jesus will make. The story emphasizes lessons of compassion, humility, and the role of animals in the nativity story.
Mary's Deductions
Mary deduces that her son is both a good man and a criminal, and realizes the contradiction lies in the laws themselves.
The True Identity of the Angel
The angel is revealed to be Lucifer, the fallen angel, who attempted to deceive Mary and tempt Jesus.
Mary's Choice and Defiance
Mary chooses not to exercise God's power and determines that her son's life is not hers to take, defying the angel and asserting her faith in God's will.
The Star Over Bethlehem
The star over Bethlehem is revealed to be Lucifer falling from the sky in his rage and failure, signaling his return to hell.
The Importance of Low Anthropology
In this podcast episode, the concept of low anthropology is explored, which challenges the idea of a high or optimistic anthropology that expects people to constantly improve and meet high expectations. The speaker argues that having a more realistic set of expectations for human nature can lead to greater ability to love ourselves and others. The biblical basis for this philosophy is also discussed, highlighting the idea that the Bible portrays the brokenness and weakness of human nature, emphasizing the need for redemption and mercy.
Miss Marple as the Iconic Christian
The podcast delves into the character of Miss Marple and how she embodies the philosophy of low anthropology. It is argued that Miss Marple's ability to recognize the faults of her fellow man while still practicing mercy and justice aligns with the biblical view of human nature. The discussion also considers how Miss Marple may be Agatha Christie's way of teaching herself to be realistic and stop being naive, following her own experiences of betrayal. The enduring popularity of mysteries, including those featuring Miss Marple, is seen as a way for readers to explore their own low anthropology and find catharsis.
And you thought the days of bumper-sized episodes of All About Agatha were behind you.... This one might be a bit of a cheat, since it's a Frankenstein's monster (a Bella Baxter?!) of a few different things: 1) a nice long "mail bag"/"housekeeping" segment; 2) a fresh episode analyzing "The Naughty Donkey" in Christie's Star Over Bethlehem and Other Stories collection; and 3) a rerun of the episode I aired in the summer this year with Sarah Hinlicky Wilson co-hosting, in which we discussed the titular story of the same collection.
So much Christie, so much Christianity, so much Christmas. Rejoice!
You can check out Sarah's short story podcast here.
You can see my upcoming book tour events (!!) here. Please come see me!
You can pre-order my mystery novel, The Busy Body, in the United States here, in the United Kingdom here, and in Australia and New Zealand here.
You can visit and subscribe to the podcast's Patreon page here.
This episode is sponsored by BritBox. For listeners in the U.S. and Canada, click here and use the promo code "AGATHA" at checkout for 50% off the first month of your monthly subscription.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode