How the Right is Winning Young Men (with Taylor Lorenz)
Nov 15, 2024
auto_awesome
Taylor Lorenz, an independent journalist known for her sharp insights on internet culture, dives into the troubling trend of male loneliness and the rise of toxic masculinity among young men. She discusses how the manosphere has exploited this loneliness, fueling ideologies connected to incels and figures like Andrew Tate. They critique the influence of conservative media and popular social media influencers, emphasizing the need for greater empathy and diverse progressive voices in media to counter the growing right-wing narrative.
The online far-right has successfully mobilized young male voters, revealing a dangerous trend towards misogynistic ideologies among Gen Z.
The rise of the incel movement reflects deeper cultural shifts that exacerbate male loneliness, fueled by harmful beliefs about masculinity.
A stronger leftist media infrastructure is essential to challenge the dominance of conservative influencers and engage young men with progressive narratives.
Deep dives
The Rise of Young Male Influencers
Young male influencers have played a significant role in mobilizing the young male vote toward right-wing ideologies, particularly in the context of Donald Trump's recent acceptance speech. Figures like Dana White and influencers from platforms such as NELF, Aiden Ross, and Joe Rogan were credited for helping turn out this demographic, which swung dramatically towards Trump in the latest election. CBS exit polls indicate that Trump won male voters under 30 by 18 points, mirroring the shift in voting patterns from the previous election, where Biden held the same advantage. This phenomenon raises questions about the strategies that progressives must adopt to better connect with young men who are increasingly drawn to far-right ideologies.
Understanding the Incel Movement
The incel movement, a community of involuntary celibates primarily consisting of young men, has become more radicalized and misogynistic in recent years. Initially born from feelings of rejection and hopelessness regarding dating, this movement has evolved into a culture that blames women for their lack of success in romantic relationships. The term 'incel' itself originated in the 1990s but gained significant traction in the 2010s through platforms like Reddit and 4chan, where discussions often devolved into deeply misogynistic ideologies. It's crucial to recognize that while these young men may express insecurity, their radicalization is not merely a personal issue but part of a larger cultural shift toward harmful beliefs about masculinity.
The Impact of Andrew Tate
Andrew Tate has emerged as a prominent figure within the manosphere, embodying a blend of extreme masculinity and misogyny that resonates with many young men. By presenting himself as a self-made success, he offers an appealing narrative that blames women and societal changes for men's struggles, while positioning himself as a savior for those feeling lost. Tate's rise was fueled by social media algorithms that favored his content, rapidly amplifying his message and influencing millions of impressionable young men. His brand of hyper-masculine rhetoric breeds a toxic culture that not only empowers incels but also cultivates a sense of hopelessness among young men who feel they are failing in a changing world.
The Male Loneliness Epidemic
The concept of a 'male loneliness epidemic' has gained traction, suggesting that traditional gender roles' erosion leaves young men feeling disconnected and uncertain about their identities. In contrast to past generations, where masculinity had clearer definitions, today's young men often struggle with their roles in a society that no longer values traditional breadwinner dynamics. While it's essential to acknowledge men's experiences of loneliness, this narrative can overshadow the significant challenges faced by women and other marginalized groups. The source of this loneliness often lies within patriarchal structures that discourage emotional vulnerability and connection among men, creating a cycle that perpetuates isolation and resentment.
The Need for Leftist Media Infrastructure
There is a pressing need for a robust leftist media infrastructure to counteract the dominance of right-wing influencers who have effectively seized the digital landscape. Unlike the right, which possesses well-funded platforms and strategies to amplify conservative voices, the left lacks a cohesive support system to elevate progressive ideologies through mainstream channels. This disparity hampers the ability of leftist figures to engage with young audiences meaningfully, as traditional media outlets often fail to address relevant issues. By fostering a new generation of influential voices that prioritize empathy and progressive values, the left can begin to bridge the gap and reshape the narratives circulating in digital media spaces.
This was the first election where the online far-right radicalization of young boys and men revealed itself in exit polls. After years of being fed diet-incel podcasts, one thing is clear: Gen Z will not, by some inherent virtue of youth, save us. Today, Taylor Lorenz and I break down the “epidemic of male loneliness”, the influencers exploiting it, the conservative media machine that funds them, and why we can’t just make a “leftist Joe Rogan.”