The Herd with Colin Cowherd THE HERD - Hour 1 - The Tush Push is on life support, issues between Caleb Williams and Ben Johnson
Sep 18, 2025
The Eagles' 'Tush Push' play faces potential banning as criticism mounts. Colin explores the optics surrounding this controversial tactic following a win against the Chiefs. He also discusses the disconnect between Bears coach Ben Johnson and rookie quarterback Caleb Williams, highlighting issues in their chemistry. Additionally, the struggles of the Chiefs raise questions about quarterback dynamics in the NFL, revealing a stark divide between elite players and the rest.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Show Opener: Weather Small Talk
- Colin opens the show describing pleasant Chicago weather and contrasts it with rainy LA banter with J-Mac.
- The small talk sets a casual tone before football topics begin.
Tush Push: Strategy Versus Optics
- Colin Cowherd argues the 'tush push' is football strategy but is endangered by optics and overuse.
- He says rules change when a tactic becomes protocol and ruins television and safety optics.
Why One Team's Edge Invites Rule Change
- Cowherd notes the play's success centers on Jalen Hurts' unique traits, not just scheme.
- He warns league rules shift when one team exploits a move repeatedly and it dominates TV value.