The Michael Shermer Show

Would You Want to Know If You Were Wrong?

23 snips
Sep 28, 2026
Barry Markovsky, a distinguished sociology professor emeritus and social psychologist, explores why extraordinary experiences feel convincing. He recounts a childhood UFO sighting and a supposedly haunted vape shop, then examines belief, identity, social groups, Ouija boards, coincidences, UAPs, consciousness, and failed paranormal replications. It is a lively tour of skepticism, uncertainty, and the forces that shape what people accept as real.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Belief Exists On A Multidimensional Spectrum

  • Paranormal belief varies by intensity, importance, social context, and source rather than fitting a simple believer-versus-skeptic split.
  • Polls asking whether someone believes in astrology capture only a narrow slice of that multidimensional distribution.
ANECDOTE

A Childhood UFO Became An Airplane

  • At age 12, Barry Markovsky and a friend watched a light repeatedly move across the sky and imagined aliens searching for somewhere to land.
  • Decades later, map work suggested the light was probably an airplane circling near Boston’s Logan Airport.
ANECDOTE

The Vape Shop Bible Mystery

  • Videos from a supposedly haunted vape shop showed orbs, voices, and a Bible flying from a desk.
  • Barry Markovsky explained most footage naturally but reserved judgment on the book, requiring better evidence before accepting a ghost.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app