René Oudmaijer, a senior scientist at the Royal Observatory of Belgium, joins the discussion about why a couple in Ostend perceives their home getting sunnier. They explore celestial anomalies, tectonic movements, and structural issues that might explain the unusual sunlight shifts. The team even considers the possibility of memory tricks playing a role. Will scientific inquiries unveil the truth behind this intriguing phenomenon?
Expert consultations reveal that changes in the Earth's axial tilt and tectonic plate movements are too slow to explain sudden sunlight increases.
The possibility of false beliefs suggests that David and Tatiana's perception of sunlight changes may be influenced by memory rather than actual environmental shifts.
Deep dives
Mystery of the Shifting Sunlight
David and Tatiana have observed a notable increase in sunlight entering their bedroom over the years, prompting them to question the cause behind this change. Their theories include possible shifts in the Earth's axis, tectonic plate movement, or even the sinking of their seaside town, Ostend. Despite their meticulous observations, the investigation reveals that these theories are much too slow to account for any significant difference perceived within their relatively short tenure in the apartment. This inconsistency leads to a deeper inquiry into the potential impacts of gradual planetary changes versus human perception of time and memory.
Scientific Investigations into Earth's Movement
Experts were consulted to evaluate the viability of David and Tatiana's theories about Earth’s tilt and tectonic plate shifts. A visit to the Royal Observatory confirmed that while the Earth's axial tilt does change, it occurs at such a slow rate that it would take thousands of years to noticeably affect sunlight in their apartment. Furthermore, interactions with a geologist clarified that tectonic plates move at a rate comparable to fingernail growth, making it impossible for David and Tatiana to perceive such shifts in their daily lives. Thus, both theories were effectively ruled out as explanations for the changes observed in their sunlight exposure.
Exploring Psychological Factors
The investigation culminated in a discussion with a memory expert who suggested that David and Tatiana might be experiencing false beliefs rather than false memories regarding their perceptions of sunlight changes. False beliefs develop over time and can alter how individuals interpret their surroundings, leading to a conviction that something has changed when, in fact, it has not. This psychological angle opens up new possibilities, suggesting that their repeated discussions about the sunlight may have crafted a narrative that feels real to them despite the lack of scientific evidence. Ultimately, the exploration concludes with an unresolved mystery, inviting further inquiries from listeners for potential solutions.
CrowdScience listeners David and Tatiana have long been captivated by an unusual dinner table discussion: the peculiar change they’ve noticed over the past 16 years in the sunlight streaming through their bedroom window in Ostend, Belgium. They’re convinced that the room has not only become sunnier but that the actual angle of sunlight has shifted.
Intrigued by their observations, we head to Ostend. Our mission: to investigate three of their theories, enlisting expert help along the way.
Theory 1 – A celestial anomaly?
René Oudmaijer at the Royal Observatory of Belgium considers whether our shifting position in the solar system might explain the change.
Theory 2 – Movement in the Earth’s crust?
Alejandra Tovar from the Geological Survey of Belgium examines tectonic data to see if the Earth’s crust is moving enough to alter the angle of sunlight.
Theory 3 – Subsidence?
Structural engineer Kath Hannigan helps us inspect the building for signs that it may be sinking or twisting.
And we explore one final theory of our own, enlisting memory expert Julia Shaw to examine whether it could all be a trick of the mind.
Will the team crack the case?
Presenter: Caroline Steel
Producer: Harrison Lewis
Editor: Cathy Edwards
Production co-ordinator: Ishmael Soriano
Studio Manager: Sarah Hockley
(Photo: CrowdScience listeners David and Tatiana standing in front of a window in their house)
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode