Harold Pinter vs The Critics

May 19, 2025

12:13

forum

Ask episode

view_agenda

Chapters

auto_awesome

Transcript

info_circle

Episode notes

Nobel Prize-winning dramatist Harold Pinter's London premiere of his debut, ‘The Birthday Play’ was detested by most critics - on 19th May, 1958.

Set in a mundane seaside boarding house, the play initially lures audiences in with a naturalistic facade, before plunging them into a perplexing, uncomfortable narrative. Critics lambasted the production for its nonsensical dialogue and lack of clarity; lines of attack which were not eased by Pinter's lifelong refusal to offer explanations. The sole exception was a positive review from The Sunday Times’s Harold Hobson - but this was printed after the show had already been pulled.

In this episode, The Retrospectors explain how Pinter’s play nonetheless left a lasting impact on British theatre; reveal who ‘Betrayal’ was REALLY about; and attempt to quantify the value of the Pinteresque pause...