Mary Edwards, "Sartre’s Existential Psychoanalysis: Knowing Others" (Bloomsbury, 2022)
Aug 19, 2023
auto_awesome
Mary Edwards, expert on Jean-Paul Sartre, discusses Sartre's existential psychoanalysis and his unique method of understanding individuals while respecting their freedom. They explore the possibility of combining Sartre's existentialism with psychoanalysis, discuss Sartre's method in psychoanalysis and its application to Jean Genet and Charles Baudelaire, and analyze Flaubert's self-formation process through Sartre's existential psychoanalysis. They also delve into Sartre's theories on imagination, the implications of the new theory presented in the book, and the importance of understanding others for self-analysis.
Sartre's philosophy integrates existentialism, psychoanalysis, and studies of oppression to provide a sophisticated understanding of human freedom.
Sartre's approach to psychoanalysis rejects Freud's dynamic conception of the unconscious and emphasizes the impact of social forces on individual experience.
Deep dives
Understanding Sartre's Existential Psychoanalysis
Sartre's Existential Psychoanalysis explores the intersection between Sartre's philosophy and psychoanalysis. Mary Edwards, a philosophy lecturer, delves into Sartre's lesser-known works and his interest in questions that psychoanalysts also explore. She highlights how Sartre's later works synthesize existentialism, historical materialism, psychoanalysis, and studies of oppression to provide a sophisticated understanding of human freedom. Edwards argues that Sartre's philosophy moves away from individual subjectivity and emphasizes the impact of social forces on individual experience. She also discusses the possibility of developing an existential psychoanalysis that rejects Freud's dynamic conception of the unconscious. Edwards believes that Sartre's approach can provide meaningful insights into understanding human behavior and the structures of oppression.
Sartre's Study of Flaubert's 'Madame Bovary' and the Fourth Volume
Sartre intended to write a fourth volume of his study on Flaubert, specifically focusing on a literary critique of 'Madame Bovary.' He planned to apply structuralist methods of criticism to interpret the text and let it speak for itself. The study of 'Madame Bovary' was seen as a test of Sartre's method, as it would provide confirmation and verification of the results from the previous volumes. Sartre believed that the critique would offer objective analysis and showcase the transformation and self-formation of Flaubert through his masterpiece.
Sartre's 'The Imaginary' and its Evolution in his Later Work
Sartre's book 'The Imaginary' explores the role of the imagination in human experience. However, as Sartre progressed as a philosopher, he found the limitations of generalizations in traditional philosophical texts frustrating. He shifted towards more concrete studies, exemplified by 'The Family Idiot.' This evolution led to a more mature form of his earlier ideas on imagination. 'The Family Idiot' combines philosophy with in-depth analysis, aiming to understand individuals as both universal and singular. Sartre's existential framework provides a theoretical basis for integrative psychotherapy, emphasizing the need for a human perspective and addressing power imbalances between therapist and client.
Thinking of the French philosopher Jean-Paul Sartre, it is hard to think of him without imagining him in very particular contexts. One will likely imagine him in a Parisian cafe working through a pack of cigarettes and coffee, working on his latest play while waiting for his friend Pierre to arrive. His theories of freedom against the temptations of bad faith are thought to be theories of writers and activists, resisters of occupation. But while this is no doubt a central part of his thinking, it misses another context he was very much interested in: the clinic. While he was not an orthodox Freudian or trained analyst, he was deeply interested in many of the questions that psychoanalysts are also interested in, and this intersection proved to be very productive, generating thousands of pages of lesser known works.
This is what Mary Edwards, philosophy lecturer at Cardiff University, has written about in her new book Sartre’s Existential Psychoanalysis: Knowing Others(Bloomsbury, 2022). Working through Sartre’s output from beginning to end, it first sets the stage with his early claims about the nature of the self and the possibility of knowing a person. From there, it works to his later works, in particular his voluminous yet unfinished biography of Gustave Flaubert, where Edwards finds Sartre developing and applying a very particular method of understanding a person while nonetheless maintaining a respect for their free nature. While Sartre never completed his intended project, Edwards finds his attempt suggestive for rethinking life both in and beyond the clinic.