Explore the origins and manipulation of the New York Times Best Seller list, including tactics used by authors. Learn about the power and prestige of being a best-selling author and the undisclosed method of calculation. Discover the controversial rise of 'Handbook for Models' to the top of the list and the aftermath of the controversy. Delve into the fascination with cheating the bestseller list and stories of individuals who have found loopholes.
38:09
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
The New York Times Best Seller list started as a calculation of book sales in New York City and later expanded nationwide, impacting the prestige and sales of authors who make the list.
Questionable tactics like bulk purchases and the use of marketing firms can be employed to manipulate book sales and secure a spot on the New York Times Best Seller list.
Deep dives
The Fascinating History of the New York Times Bestsellers List
The podcast episode explores the history and significance of the New York Times bestsellers list. It reveals that the list was initially limited to calculating book sales in New York City but later expanded to include sales nationwide. The episode discusses the various categories and genres included in the list, with a focus on fiction and nonfiction. It also highlights the importance and prestige of being a New York Times bestseller, citing a study that shows an increase in sales for debut authors who make the list. The podcast explores the methods of calculating the list and the potential for gaming the system. It delves into the use of bulk purchases and marketing firms to artificially boost book sales and secure a spot on the list. The episode also features a case study of a controversial book, "Handbook for Mortals," which managed to reach number one on the young adult hardcover bestsellers list through questionable means.
The Controversial Case of "Handbook for Mortals"
The podcast episode delves into the story of "Handbook for Mortals," a controversial book that was initially published by Geek Nation Press. It reveals that the author, Lani Saram, and her business partner, Thomas Ian Nicholas, employed marketing firms to buy bulk copies of the book and manipulate sales numbers. The episode discusses the skepticism surrounding the book's sudden rise to the top of the New York Times bestsellers list and the subsequent investigation that uncovered the unethical practices. It highlights the public backlash and review bombing the book received, while also questioning the financial aspects of the scheme. The episode explores Lani's attempts to defend her actions through op-eds in various publications and the ultimate failure of her publishing venture.
The Influence and Significance of Bestseller Lists
The podcast episode explores the influence and significance of bestseller lists, specifically focusing on the New York Times list. It discusses how landing on the list increases book sales and offers a public endorsement of an author's work. The episode highlights the complex nature of calculating the list and the mystery surrounding the New York Times' undisclosed method. It mentions the inclusion criteria and exclusions of certain genres, such as textbooks and crossword puzzles. Additionally, the episode touches on the power of being labeled a New York Times bestseller and the potential benefits for authors in terms of book deals and wider recognition.
Gaming the Bestsellers List
The podcast episode explores the topic of gaming the bestsellers list and the questionable tactics authors and publishers employ to secure a spot on the New York Times list. It discusses the case of bulk purchases and marketing firms hired to artificially inflate book sales and manipulate rankings. The episode highlights the consequences faced by authors and publishers who engage in unethical practices, including the removal of books from the list and the use of a dagger symbol to indicate suspicious sales. It also delves into the debate around what constitutes gaming the system and the blurry line between legitimate strategies and deceptive practices.
Today, Eilish Gilligan and Zara McDonald are breaking down the surprising history of the New York Times Best Seller list, and the shady things some authors have done to land a spot on the list…
Big thanks to Baileys for making this episode possible. If you are over 18 and interested in an indulgent treat then head online or in-store to shop Baileys. Remember to Drink Responsibly.
This episode was audio produced by Eilish Gilligan.
You can browse the eBook and audiobook versions of past book club picks in our room on Apple Books! Have a look-see right here. (You might spot our little baby, The Space Between, in the mix there, too.)
Want to support our show? We are sending air kisses, air tea, and air hugs (too far?) to anyone who clicks ‘subscribe’ on Apple (bonus hugs for anyone who leaves a five-star review, too) or ‘follow’ on Spotify.
Still not enough? Well! Our hearts! See below for everything else.