In this podcast, Jonah Goldberg covers a range of interesting topics, including China's economy, the illiberal regime, Russia, coalitional instincts, Clarence Thomas controversy, Mitch McConnell's health, and civic ignorance in American life.
01:37:42
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
China's economy is facing challenges as foreign investment dries up and debt continues to rise, contributing to further economic decline in the long run.
Technology has a greater impact on how we live and think, shaping society and people's behavior more than intellectual ideas.
Civic ignorance is a longstanding problem in America, but regardless of civic knowledge, Americans generally favor liberal democratic capitalism as a system.
Deep dives
China's Turn Towards Nationalism and Its Economic Troubles
China's economy is facing challenges as foreign investment dries up and debt continues to rise. The Chinese Communist Party, under the leadership of Xi Jinping, is turning away from capitalism and towards nationalism to maintain control. However, this move away from economic freedom is likely to contribute to further economic decline in the country in the long run. The Chinese government's refusal to prioritize transparency, accountability, and the rule of law has led to politically corrupted markets and a debt crisis. Additionally, China's discriminatory policies against non-Han Chinese citizens and its use of slave labor also make it a Jim Crow or apartheid country. Despite these issues, some Western institutions and elites continue to do business with China, turning a blind eye to its human rights violations.
The Importance of Technological Impact Over Intellectual Influence
The role of technology in shaping society and people's behavior is often underestimated. Intellectuals tend to overemphasize the power of ideas, while technology has a greater impact on how we live and think. American society, for example, is largely shaped by Western-style liberal democratic capitalism, regardless of whether individuals can articulate the philosophical principles behind it. The average American's knowledge of civics may be lacking, but their cultural common sense informs their resistance to infringements on constitutional rights. Ideas alone cannot change people's deeply ingrained cultural values and inclinations.
Civic Ignorance and Support for Socialism
Civic ignorance, as evidenced by surveys on Americans' knowledge of their own history and government, is a longstanding problem. However, it is not the lack of knowledge about specific ideas such as those of John Locke that shape American attitudes towards governance and economics. Regardless of civic knowledge, Americans generally favor liberal democratic capitalism as a system. Polls may suggest support for socialism or welfare state policies, but when faced with the costs associated with these policies, such as tax increases, support diminishes. Claims that Americans embrace socialism are often rooted in a misunderstanding of public opinion. misunderstanding of public opinion.
McConnell's position and age limits
Despite criticisms from both the left and the right, the speaker rejects most of the criticism towards Mitch McConnell, seeing him as a good person, an institutionalist, and being right on major policy issues. However, the speaker believes that McConnell's tenure in the Senate is not sustainable in the medium term. The idea of imposing age limits as a way to address this issue is considered legitimate, even though the speaker is more sympathetic to age limits than term limits. The speaker highlights the potential partisan biases involved in discussing age limits, using the example of people who previously defended Dianne Feinstein’s position but are now critical of McConnell.
The partisanship in coverage of Supreme Court ethics
The speaker criticizes the partisan nature of the coverage surrounding Supreme Court justices' ethical issues. By citing specific examples of both conservative and liberal justices, the speaker argues that there is a double standard in media coverage and selective outrage based on the court's ideological composition. The speaker questions the credibility of certain news outlets, claiming that they often present biased perspectives disguised as objective opinions. Additionally, the speaker highlights the role of partisan organizations and politicians in delegitimizing the Supreme Court due to its conservative majority, suggesting that this behavior undermines the court's integrity.
Ignoring the desperate pleas of those closest to him, Jonah reaches new heights of excess on today’s needlessly long Ruminant. Still on a China kick, he begins by addressing the country’s spiraling economy and illiberal regime, but quickly becomes distracted by a handful of similarly grim topics, including the awfulness of Russia and the poisonous role of the coalitional instinct in American life. Stick around for musings on the Clarence Thomas controversy, Mitch McConnell’s health, and civic ignorance in American life. Oh, and to hear a few intimate details about the discomfort Jonah feels when staring at himself for an extended period.