Phillip Magness, a tax historian, joins the discussion to delve into the historical significance of tariffs in U.S. revenue generation, particularly before the federal income tax was introduced. The conversation touches on Trump's recent executive order about Title IX and transgender athletes, emphasizing its political implications. They also explore the complexities of school choice initiatives and the evolving landscape of education reform. Intriguingly, they contemplate the possibility of revitalizing tariffs as a major funding source for the federal government.
The podcast discusses Trump's executive order on Title IX, highlighting a contentious debate about fairness for cisgender female athletes versus transgender participation in sports.
The conversation also addresses the push for school choice as a critical civil right, challenging traditional educational structures and union influence in the wake of pandemic-related challenges.
Deep dives
Executive Order on Women's Sports
President Trump signed an executive order banning biological males from competing in female sports, a move framed as promoting fairness and safety in athletics. This decision sparked discussions around its political implications, with proponents arguing it addresses a significant concern for female athletes. The order aims to reverse prior Biden administration guidance that encouraged transgender participation in women's sports, emphasizing the distinction based on chromosomes rather than personal identity. Critics, however, highlight potential legal ramifications that may arise from reinstating a binary classification in policy.
Impact of Transgender Athletes in Sports
The debate centers on fairness in competition, particularly as experiences of transgender athletes like Leah Thomas have reignited discussions about their participation in women's events. Critics argue that biological differences confer competitive advantages that compromise the integrity of women's sports, creating disparities that are perceived as fundamentally unfair. While acknowledging the need for accommodating transgender individuals in sports, the conversation emphasizes the necessity of protecting opportunities for cisgender female athletes. The implications for high school and college competitions have further fueled this discourse, with significant stakeholders advocating for policy clarity.
School Choice and Educational Reform
Trump's administration is prioritizing school choice, advocating for policies that empower parents to select educational institutions for their children, especially in the wake of challenges posed by the pandemic. The push for school choice is framed as a critical civil right, seeking to eliminate the confines of underperforming government-run schools. This move poses a direct challenge to powerful teachers' unions that have historically resisted such initiatives, signaling a shift in the educational landscape. Supporters argue that enhancing school choice will foster better educational outcomes and accountability within the system.
Government Funding of Media Outlets
The podcast discusses concerns over Politico's substantial government contracts for subscriptions, raising questions about the ethical implications of taxpayer dollars supporting media organizations. Critics argue that these funding arrangements could compromise journalistic independence and promote biased coverage, particularly given Politico's past reporting on politically sensitive topics. Advocates for reform suggest that this practice not only wastes taxpayer money but also blurs the lines between independent journalism and government influence. The conversation prompts broader reflections on the role of government in media funding and the potential need for regulatory scrutiny.
Andrew Walworth, Tom Bevan, and Carl Cannon discuss Trump's executive order regarding Title IX and transgender participation in women's sports. They also talk about the federal government's cancellation of contracts with Politico and CBS’s decision to release the unedited version of Kamala Harris' 60 Minutes interview in response to an FCC investigation and a Trump lawsuit. Plus, they discuss Department of Education reform, Trump's executive orders regarding school choice, and they look forward to next week’s confirmation hearings for Linda McMahon to become Secretary of Education. Then finally, Andrew talks to tax historian Phillip Magness about tariffs, taxes and whether Trump can return us to the days when tariffs were the major revenue source for the federal government.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode