The Daily Punch Inside Thune's health care decision day
Dec 9, 2025
Tension mounts in the Republican party as they scramble for a coherent health care strategy. The Senate is under pressure, particularly on Senate Majority Leader Thune, to present a viable alternative to the Democrats' plan. Meanwhile, House Republicans face chaos with uncertain leadership and a potential skipped vote on extending Obamacare subsidies. Over in Texas, the GOP primary is descending into a messy runoff, creating significant concerns for party unity moving forward. Plus, a new defense newsletter launch adds another layer to the political landscape.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Use A Discharge Petition To Force Action
- Force a House vote if leadership won't act by using a discharge petition to compel consideration.
- A bipartisan group led by Brian Fitzpatrick is pursuing that route to extend enhanced Obamacare subsidies and push Speaker Mike Johnson.
Not Offering Alternatives Is Political Risk
- Senate Republicans risk political damage by offering only criticism without an alternative health plan.
- Jake Sherman and Anna Palmer argue that failing to present a GOP alternative will signal indifference and hurt them politically.
Put A Bill On The Floor Rather Than Sit Idle
- Put forward a GOP bill even if it might fail so senators can at least vote on something.
- Jake Sherman recommends offering a Republican alternative to avoid appearing directionless.