France is facing a constitutional crisis, with President Macron losing his parliamentary majority and no clear successor in sight. The rise of far-right leaders, anti-NATO and pro-Putin sentiments, and dissatisfaction with Macron's government contribute to the turmoil. The yellow vest protests and the controversy surrounding Macron's use of clause 49.3 are discussed. The lasting influence of the Algerian War on treatment of certain individuals and the rise of far-right parties, including Marine Le Pen's National Rally, are explored.
The concentration of power in the hands of the French President, as outlined in the constitution, is raising concerns about the stability of the country's institutions.
The current political turmoil in France, combined with a fractured party system, has led to a domination of the political center and limited possibilities for alternative political movements.
Deep dives
France's Constitutional Crisis
The podcast explores the possibility of France heading towards a constitutional crisis. The current political turmoil in France is raising concerns about the stability of the country's institutions. Many French citizens believe that their national malaise is due to the concentration of power in the hands of one man. The French Republic's constitution, designed by Charles de Gaulle, gives extensive powers to the President. However, critics argue that the presidential system encourages abuse of power, marginalizes parliamentary democracy, and institutionalizes state racism. The recent protests, including the Yellow Vest movement and demonstrations against police violence, reflect the deep dissatisfaction with the current constitutional framework.
The Power of the French President
The Fifth Republic's constitution grants significant powers to the French President. The President has authority to appoint the Prime Minister, dissolve Parliament, and impose laws without a vote through Clause 49.3. The President's ability to bypass parliamentary procedures has sparked controversy. While some argue that these powers allow for strong leadership and stability, others criticize the top-down approach and lack of consideration for public opinion. The influence of the President, combined with a fractured party system, has led to a domination of the political center, leaving little room for alternative political movements. The presidential system is also seen as susceptible to far-right candidates like Marine Le Pen.
Calls for Constitutional Change
The dissatisfaction with the current constitutional setup has led to calls for constitutional change in France. Critics argue that the Constitution has not kept pace with societal changes and that it needs to be recalibrated to rebalance power between the President and other institutions. There is a desire for a more democratic system that is responsive to the needs and voices of the people. While some advocate for profound constitutional change, others suggest a recalibration of presidential powers to ensure a more balanced governance model. The future of the Fifth Republic and the potential of a Le Pen presidency are subjects of deep concern and uncertainty.
The USA, the UK and France, which have led the democratic world, are all suffering problems with their constitutions. But the problem is most acute in France, where President Macron has lost his parliamentary majority, and forced his pension reforms through by decree. But worse is to come; Macron can only serve as President until 2027 and will leave a vacuum at the heart of French politics when he steps down. And unlike Charles de Gaulle, he doesn’t seem likely to leave an enduring movement or an obvious successor. He hoovered up centrist support when he swept to power, and his main rivals now are either far-left or far-right. They both are populists, anti-NATO and pro-Putin. Edward Stourton explores if France is heading towards a constitutional crisis and asks what political turmoil in our nearest neighbour might mean.
Presenter: Edward Stourton
Producer: Jonathan IAnson
Editor: Clare Fordham
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode