Phil Vischer, Part 2: Fighting To Save Evangelicalism From Fundamentalism
Aug 30, 2023
auto_awesome
Phil Vischer, Christian media pioneer, joins the podcast to discuss the definition of evangelicalism. They explore controversies surrounding the term, analyze the complexities of political power, and emphasize the value of epistemic humility and creating safe spaces for pastors to navigate difficult questions.
Phil Vischer highlights the importance of epistemic humility and the need for a centrist evangelicalism that upholds essential beliefs while embracing biblical teaching on gender, social concern, and caring for the marginalized.
The contested nature of evangelical identity is discussed, with concerns about Southern fundamentalism shaping the global perception of evangelicalism. Historical and cultural factors, such as the Civil War and Jim Crow era, are explored, highlighting the impact of the Southern Church on evangelicalism worldwide.
Deep dives
The Importance of Epistemic Humility and Centrist Evangelicalism
In this episode, the hosts engage in a conversation with Phil Vischer, the co-creator of Veggie Tales, discussing his identification as an evangelical. Phil highlights the importance of epistemic humility, acknowledging that he does not have all the answers and that his understanding of the Bible is not definitive. He expresses his interest in a centrist evangelicalism that upholds the essential beliefs of the faith, embraces biblical teaching on gender and sexuality, and demonstrates a commitment to social concern and caring for the marginalized. Phil emphasizes the need for constructive dialogue and a willingness to study nuanced issues without always needing a definitive stance.
The Shifting Dynamics of Evangelical Identity
The conversation delves into the contested nature of evangelical identity and the ongoing struggle for ownership of the term. Phil and the hosts explore how evangelicalism has been influenced by both Northern evangelicalism and Southern fundamentalism, with a concern that the worst aspects of Southern fundamentalism are shaping the global perception of evangelicalism. They touch on the historical and cultural factors that have shaped these dynamics, including the Civil War and Jim Crow era, and how the Southern Church's influence is impacting evangelicalism on a global scale.
Navigating Controversial Issues with Epistemic Humility
The podcast discussion also addresses the challenge of navigating controversial topics within evangelicalism. Phil emphasizes the importance of not policing boundaries or resorting to reactive separatisms. Instead, he encourages a middle ground that follows Jesus and seeks to be constructive towards creation, while also holding firmly to essential Christian beliefs. The hosts highlight the complexity of issues like civil unions and the need for Christians to engage in humble, thoughtful study and individual interpretation rather than seeking definitive answers without intellectual exploration.
The Call for Clarity and Constructive Dialogue
The podcast conversation concludes with a focus on the need for clarity and constructive dialogue within evangelicalism. While Phil advocates for epistemic humility and refrains from definitive statements on certain topics, there is a call for individuals to clearly articulate their beliefs and positions. The hosts emphasize the importance of finding common ground amidst diverse perspectives and holding each other in love and respect, even when disagreements arise. The conversation ultimately encourages pastors and church leaders to create safe spaces for individuals with questions, fostering honest exploration and intellectual growth.
Phil Vischer joins “The Stetzer ChurchLeaders Podcast,” where he shares his perspective on who is currently defining what it means to be an "evangelical" and what he believes the term should represent.